---------------------------------------------------------------
© Copyright
---------------------------------------------------------------
..
-
( )
--------------------------------------------------------------
1. .
1. .
2. , , . XVI
.. .
3. -
XVI .
3.1.
.
3.1.1. -, , ,
.
3.1.2. .
3.1.3. .
3.2. .
XIX .
4. .
5. .
. . .
6. . : "
". " ".
7. . .
8. , ?
.
9. .
10. .
11. .
12.
.
13. "" ?
14.
.
15.
.
15.1.
.
15.2. , -
- .
16. ?
2. .
1. " .
2. ?
3.
".
4. .
3.
.
1. .
.
2. .
.
3. .
4. .
.
5.
.
6. .
.
7. .
8. .
9. . .
10. .
11. . .
12. -.
13.
.
4.
1. " "
-.
2. - "
-".
3. - "
-".
4. , .
5. "
-". .
6. " "
-.
7. ,
.
8. .
9. : , ,
X .., .. -
X ..
10. .
11.
.
11.1.
11.2.
.
11.3. .
XV-XVI .
11.4. ,
. : X.III
-: III .
5. " " .
1. .
2. -
.
3. - ?
4. .
5. ?
6. . , .
--------------------------------------------------------------------
XVI ..
-
.
(. 1). ,
.
1975
, ,
. ,
,
. . . ,
, ,
.
.
, .
.-., .. (-
, , .)
.-.,
...
, ,
,
.. ...
" ,
(, XXX .
..); ,
,
..."
, " ", ., 1975,
. 27, . 23
. ,
,
,
,
, ( .. ..).
,
, .
, , ,
, ..
XVI-XIX . ,
.
, -
,
, , "
" [19], .77 .
, ( ) "
" .
.
,
,
XVI-XVII .,
(1540-1609) - "
" [19], .82, . [344] (Scaliger I. Opus novum de emendatione
temporum. Lutetiac. Paris, 1583. Thesaurum temporum. 1606),
() (1583-1652), . [327] (Petavius D. De
doctrina temporum. Paris. 1627).
,
XVIII-XIX . [266],
[284], [293], [306]. ( )
, , .:
" ,
" [19], .90, .1.
" -".
.
, ,
.
,
,
,
,
, ,
.
, ,
.
(XVI-XVII .)
;
. , "
, ,
, " [51], .105.
,
(IV ...) . . "
" (.. "")
. :
" ( - ..)
. "
[68], .VIII, . , XIV
, ..
"" "" , "
, " [68], .XI.
1544 . (. [68],
.XIII), .. , :
""
?
(IV ...)
XVI-XVII . ,
( ,
, , . ..).
,
, .
,
, " ",
:
. (, ),
23 4004 . .. [20]. ,
" " :
"
...
" [19], .82.
".,
, , - ,
., - ,
(! - ..), "
[19], .82.
, " ", ,
(
; - ..):
5969 (, , . ),
5508 (, ),
5493 (, , 5472 5624),
4004 (, ),
5872 ( 70 ),
4700 (),
3761 (),
3491 (),
5199 ( ),
5500 ( ),
5515 (, 5507),
5551 () .. [19], .69.
(
) 2100 .
,
, 200 (!) "
".
" "
, .
,
" ",
""
. ""
( XVIII )
. , .
"" [68], .XIII,
.
, XVI-XVII .
" ".
. ( )
( )
.
, ,
"". ""
XVII-XVIII
.,
.
XIX
,
, XIX
.
XX ,
,
"" , , , , ,
, , , .
XX ,
, ,
.
,
. , ,
[19], .83.
" "
226 ,
557 ( 300 )
[19], .83.
" 52
, II 206
( . - ..) [19], .83.
,
: " ,
, "
[19], .77. , , , "
,
XIV ."
[19], .69.
3.1. .
3.1.1. -, , , .
. , .. , "
- (de Arcilla) XVI
Programma Historiae Universalis
Divinae Florac Historicae, ,
,
(J.Hardouin, 1646-1724),
XVI ... -
1902-1903 " ",
,
, -
"
[141], .2, .VII-VIII, .
(1842-1901),
. , .
, : "
,
" [426], .XXX.
!
. XIX - XX [426],
[427].
3.1.2. .
" (1642-1727), ,
, ,
, (1672)
( 1703) ...
( .)
.
, ,
,
, ,
. .
. ,
,
"
.
., 1979, .903.
-
. - ,
.
, .
. (.[314]):
1) " ,
",
2) " " (.1).
- , .
. ( )
. , ,
. ,
.. ( ), XIV ..
,
( ).
( ). (
) ,
, .. . ,
,
IV .. ,
..
" - , ,
.
,
" [158],.104-105.
,
, . :
", ,
, ,
,
,
, ,
, . .
: "
, ...
...
, ,
.
, ,
"..." [158],.106-107.
?
..
" " , , :
.
,
() 3000
. ..
, 946
. .. , , 2000 .
XV ..,
, 936 . ..
, 700 .
1225
.. [19], ,
904 . .. , 330
. .
, .
( )
300 ( ).
(, , -
3000 . .. )
330 : 946 . ..
617 . .. ,
1800 .
200 . ..
-
( )
.
., [425]. . ,
-, ,
.
1728 .
1727 . , " "
.
.
,
. (Abbe Conti).
, ,
.
. (M.Freret)
,
.
G.Gavelier', , ,
( 1724 ). ,
1725 , ,
( ). .
Gavelier
. 27 1725
. . :
Abrege de Chronologie de M.Le Chevalier Newton, fait par lui-
-meme, et traduit sur le manuscript Angelois. (With observation by
M.Freret). Edited by the Abbe Conti, 1725.
11 1725 .
(Transactions of
the Royal Society, v.33, 1725, p.315),
.
Father Souciet 1726 ,
,
.
. ,
,
. 1727 ,
.
" "?
?
( XVIII )
. ,
("
" .). , ,
, .
.
"
" " " :
", ,
,
, ,
. - , ,
"", "" " ",
, ,
" (., "
". , - , 1995, .63).
..,
.
. ,
.
3.1.3. .
"..
,
.
, ,
, ."
:
. .: , 1981, .284.
,
, (.2).
.. (1854-1946) -
-. .
- -
.
I. -
.
.. ..,
, ,
.
.. . 1881
,
, , , ,
. 1905 , 25
.
- ; -
- ..
.
(
)
.
1922 . - ( 1925 . -
).
1907 . .. " "
[139], ""
, . 1914 . -
"" [140],
.
1924-1932 . ..
"" [141], "
",
. ,
, ,
.
, ..
,
,
.
"", .. , , ,
,
.
,
.
, ""
.
, .. .
., . ,
.
,
VI ..
. ,
-
,
, . ,
, ,
. VI
.., ,
VI-XIII . ( ,
).
, , ,
. , ,
, , ,
. ,
(, ., .
..) , :
.
3.2. .
XIX .
,
. ""
XVIII - 1701 .
" ", 20-
(, .).
XIX .
, ,
. , , , :
"
, , .
,
(509 . .. - ..),
(,
673 . ..; ,
100 . - ..).
, 262 .
, ,
(348)" [137],
.876.
. ,
, , 500
[137], .876 [145], . 23-24.
, (,
IV ..), ,
( ). ,
,
, .
(, XIII ..)
(, VIII ..) 500
. , :
500 ,
500 ,
,
.
, ? "" -
? , .
, .
, ,
- . , (
- ) - ?
, , , .
" ()"
,
" ()" (,
"" ). ,
-
. , -
, .. .
, , "
;
, , "
[175], .3. , . 59 . ..
700 . 144
35; - 1469 .
; ,
5 .
. : " ...
...
,
; .
, ,
" [138],
.512.
, - : "
( . - ..)
... ( .
- ..) ,
(
,
, ,
, 500
, . [145], .23-24. - ..)...
, , ,
;
,
,
,
, , ..." (.,
[138], .513-514). . . [145],
.4-6.
,
.
,
" "
(!)
, . [239], [301].
. [365].
. : " ,
,
-. ...
, ,
" [175], . 23.
,
(.. )
. , , ""
.
, . : "
,
, , , , ,
?... ,
.
" [127], .6-7,14.
., ", ,
...
,
. , -,
, , ,
, " [127],
.20,27-28.
, . :
" 1050 ...
,
" [19], .76.
, " "
.
500-
, ,
, .
XVI
. ,
,
.
, ,
( "")
, .
:
" : ( II) - XIX
(1345-1200 . ..), - IV
(2600-2480 . ..)" [39], .513, .136.
1200 . : "
" [39], .512, .108.
"" . ,
, .. "
IV (. 2480 . ..)
(. 715 . ..)". [39], .516,
. 150. 1800 .
, -
. , , ..
, XIX .
,
, .
. : "
:
-
,
, ,
, .
,
, :
5702 ..,
- 5613 ,
- 4455 ,
- 4157 ,
- 5702 ,
- 3623 .
,
2079 ...
,
,
, ,
.
,
(.. XIX - ..)
" [22], .95-97.
.
- (.
[416]): , 3100 , 3000
.. - 2700 .
(, ) ,
:
5867 ..,
- 5770 ..,
- 5004 ..,
- 4000 ..,
- 3180 ..,
- 2850 ..,
- 2320 ..,
- 2224 .. ..
"" ""
3643 .
, , ",
, , 80
", - XIX --- [224],
.95. : " ,
, ... ,
...
" [224],.95.
,
. "
, ... , ,
... , -
., - " [36],
.15. , , "
" [36],.107.
, ,
, .
, .
, .
.
, : " ,
XIII .. (! -
! - ..). , -
., - ,
III
" [36],.61.
, -
XIX XX -
,
.
.
.
, ,
" ".
,
.
XIX (
1882-1885 . 1878 .) , ,
""
. .[8], [280] [337]. [8],
. ,
"" - (.. ),
,
-, (
).
.
[8].
, , , , ,
, , , , ,
, .. [8].
.
XV :
, , .
" ".
. :
"' ,
- , 500-1500
" [144], .69.
[26],
. ,
,
, .. " ",
[141].
, ..
IX-X . ..,
" " [221]. XIV-XV .
, " , 1420 .
... :
" "
(!- ..).
, :
...
,
(, XIII .) , ,
. ,
" " ... :
, , ,
,
, : 1428 .
.
" [221], .387-388.
" "
; "
" [185],
(. 818 . ..), , " ",
, , "
" [221], .281. .. " ",
" " [221], .271.
IX . ..,
XVI .
XI . ..
XV-XVI
. . 1497 .
[141] " " .
.. [141], .4, .624,
(!) . (, , I-II
..) ! ,
0,00007
, 0,006,
0,003 (. [141], .4, .625-626).
XV . - [122]. ,
"" "" : () - .
(1414-1472) ,
,
[122], .3-4. "" ,
,
, , , .
"" "
"
. ,
" "
[122], .152. " ".
,
( !)
. " ...
- ,
" [122], .89.
, ""
XV . ..
"
" [122], .165,167,173. "
" [122], .179.
,
, ( XV ...)
" ", " ",
, " ".
( 1497 ...)
" ",
. , XIV-XV .
" ",
. "" .
.
, . "
" [19], .73. ,
,
. " XIII-XIV
, " [364], .68.
" - ...
- .
, "
[51], .94. IX . ..
; , ()
[51], .94. XIII-XIV
., , V.
"
,
" [51], .94.
, "
" [51], .95.
. , " ,
... ,
...
...
(!-..)
" [51], .109-110.
"
, .
, ...
...
... XI
, ,
" [51], .117-118.
,
, ,
" ", " "
, ,
. , (, "
"), :
,
"" ,
.
.
.
, ,
(X-XIII . ..) -
(. [70], .1, .16), VI . .. (
).
: ", ...
, ,
,
( XIII . ..! - ..) - .
" [70], .1, .32.
(. [70]) ,
(
1273 . .., .. 1200 ), -
. XIV
. .. (" ", [70], .1, .32).
. :
" ,
( - ..),
"" "
[169], .26.
, , ,
" ".
. . [97],
, ,
XIV . ..! ,
(. 1344 . ..) [97], .212.
, , [97].
.
.
"
,
... ... (,
.. " " - ..) ... IV
. .. ...
- , ,
1475 . ...
, 1628 . ...
I" [110], .267-268.
XIX . . [110],
.268-270.
,
XV . ..
., " ".
,
.
, VI .
.. ( ), [110]. "
" [110],
.270. IX . .. (!)
, ,
XIII . ..,
. ,
, 1008 . ..
[110], .270.
,
363 . ..,
[186], .148.
,
1545 . 1563 . ( ).
,
, , "
", [186].
. ,
""
.
" ".
: " 1902
,
" [110],.273. ,
, .. , "
, ,
""
" [110], .272-
273. , "
",
. : " ( - ..)
( II ..
)" [121],.47. ,
. "
" [110],.27.
(, ..)
. "
, . ,
,
...
" [186], .155.
. , -
, " "
.
. "
( - ..) ... ( -
..) , ,
.... , ...
, -
, - (! -
..), " [19], .176.
,
, .
", ,
,
... .
...
, ...
" [186],
.155.
,
, , , ,
: , , , .. ..
..: "
" (. [186], .155). , "
VII
VIII ", ()
" ... , ;
,
" [186], .156 - 157.
: " ... VII VIII
....
, ...
.
,
... " (.
[186], .157).
" ,
V .. ... XVI XVII
, , ...
.
,
.
,
,
? ...
. :
" [186], .157-158.
,
,
, , ,
..
.
"" ,
..,
,
.
: " ...
" (. [110], .16).
,
" XIX .",
. (. [110]).
, .,
, -
: "
;
... ,
"" ,
. , ,
, , "
(. [110], .17).
,
'
. ""
[141].
(, ). "
, ,
. ,
,
, ""
, ,
,
, ,
, ..
, ,
-
( - ..).
.... , ,
. ,
,
" [110], .200-201.
. ,
(.. - " ")
:
( ),
( " ")
[218], .13,,162-165,
[69], .130,
( ),
(.. )
, .. .
, -
"", -
.
, .
-
( , ,
). (
), . (
- ) "".
,
XII-XIII . .. [19].
,
[47]. - ,
,
XIII . ..
, ,
: [147], .5, .360,
[148], .6, .126.
"" " "
[124], .1, .3-4, .1, N 1.
, [3], .88, 235, 162, 207.
: "
(
- ..) ... "
" [3], .162.
, (
- ),
, " ,
" [11], .2, .274-285. ?
.
- , -
[141], .7. : - .
-, - -.
: " ,
(! - ..)" (. [141], .893).
, ""
. ,
""?
,
,
- , ,
.
, ,
( ),
"
, ".
"", .,
1919, ..25. ,
, - . ,
- " ",
, .
,
: , , ?
. , -
, ?
[141],
.282-283.
, ""
. .
, " " ;
, .
,
[3], .255.
, : " -
, ( ? -
..)... ,
" [118], .45.
"" (
), .
, , [68], .85.
, " "" ( -
..) " [134], .266, .14.
, , ,
XI . .. [134], .9.
.
, ,
( - , ) [39],
.492. , "
XIII .
.. [39], .493.
. ,
,
, , " ",
, (
). .
, ""
( )
. , , =
= = = = =
= ([39], ., . 34, 36, 110 ...).
[141].
,
, .
: " : ,
... ...
, ( ), ( - ..)
... ,
(), ...
, , ;
, , ;
" (, XIX).
" ,
" (, XX).
" ... ...
, , " (., IV, 9-12).
: "
... , , "
(, XIX, 24, 28). ..
"" , ..
..: (XIX, 18, 24), (XIII, 21, 22), (XIV,
18), (XX, 15), (XXIV, 15, 16, 17), (XIV, 14), (XXI, 28),
(XXVI, 10), (IV, 11, 36), (V, 19, 20, 21), (IX, 15,
21), (X, 4), (XXXII, 22), 2- . (XXII, 8-10, 13), 1-
. (XVIII, 38, 39), (XIX, 11, 12), 2- . (I,
10-12, 14), (IX, 12, 19), . (.II, .6, .
106, . 17), (. 106, . 18), (XXXVIII, 22),
(XLVIII, 45), . (II, 3), (IV, 11), (IV,
5), (V, 25), (IX, 17, 18), (X, 17), (XXX, 30), (II, 3, 5,
10).
, " ".
:
. ?
C [109], .380-381,461. ,
- ;
" ", ,
, ; ..
.
,
.
[109].
, :
1) ,
,
2) - (. .),
3) - :
. , - .
.
,
. -
(""?) : (?)
(?). .
.. [141] ,
,
-- .
: " ...
: ... " ! ...
... " ( I, 7).
""
, : -
(.. ).
: " , " ( I, 7).
,
"", - , - - .
: " , ".
,
.
: "
" (. I, 19). ,
- -
, ,
.
: " -". -
"-", , ,
[141], .2, .166. ,
.
: " ".
, , :
, .
, Diablereux - .
" "
"", .. [141], .2, .167.
: " " ( II, 14).
: . -
!
: " " ( III, 1). ,
, . ,
() - Bassano - .
: " ... ...
( . - ..)" ( III, 1).
,
, , , (.
, ) - Eridanus [141],
.2),
- . [141], .2, .167.
: " ... "
( III, 3-4). ,
: , , ,
..
: " ( . - ..) ()
" ( III, 4,8).
"" .
: " , , . ,
(: - ..), , (
! - ..)" ( III, 2).
(), (""
- ?) (493-526 . ..), ! .. ..
, , ,
, ,
" " ,
, .
" ",
" ".
- "",
,
"" (205-270 . ..),
. ,
, XV . ..,
"" -
, -
. ,
"" .
XV . .. [60],
.143-147.
" " -
[60]. -
( "") "
", , .
"" .
, XV
,
. "" , (205-270)
, (
) ,
- " " [27], .4,
.394-397. "" .
,
(""
), , "
" ( )
, , , .. ,
", "
, ,
. ""
(, , )
VIII-IX . .. [92], .23.
X-XI .
, "
" [92], .83. XI .
" " (), ()
" " (, ,
..), , , ,
[92], .83-84.
" XII XIII .
: ( - ..)
; ...
" [92], .85-86. ,
(!), VII . ..
[92], .85-86.
"
.... - (-,
"" - ..)
" [92], .85-86. "
" [92], .85 - 86.
, ,
- (?) [3], .234, . 76.
, " ( - ..)
:
; ...
, - , -
. , -
, - .
" [210], .237-238.
"".
""
" "
, " "
( )
. :
, ", ",
"
". , "
"
[92].
, (
), ,
.
; ,
. ,
.
-
. (
), "" . -
"", "" ..
" III ; III
.... ( ) - , ;
, - " [154], .22.
,
, .
,
. (. 450 . ..)
-
: , , , ,
, , , , ,
.. [197]. ,
" " XII-XIV
... [416].
. (
)
. :
"" .
"' ,
- ,
500-1500
."
., "
", , 1968, .69.
,
.., .. .. [405], [407], [408],
[411], [412].
. .., ..
.. [430].
,
. -
"". ""
- , ,
, 1000 .
, ""
, , II . ..
,
( ,
"") (, II . ..). , ,
,
. , ,
"" . , :
" .
,
, ,
, ". . ..
" ". - .;.: , 1946.
VIII-IX
. .., "",
. ( )
"" IX . .. (
) [328].
"", .
. "
" [156] "
". .
, "",
"".
., .. [141]
"" (
),
, "".
""
,
, .
. ,
. ,
, (, ). ,
.
.
,
. -
( )
.
(
).
, . ,
,
. ,
"". .
?
"" ,
. 10
, .
, , , ""
350-400 . ,
100
200 .
, ,
:
) ,
, ,
,
( ..);
) , : ,
, ..;
) ,
, :
, .
,
[328].
, ,
. , , .
,
.
" " ,
, , -
. ,
, ,
. ,
, ,
,
, .
,
,
, ..
.
. -,
. -,
, :
, XIII . ..
( ,
40 , 10
- ).
. -,
, , .,
[156].
"",
.
) ,
,
20 .
) , 10
(
).
)
. - 600 .. 1300 ..
) ,
"" ( "
") 10 .
) 200 . ..
35 ,
200 . ..
.
, ,
,
"" 600
..
(,
.),
.
, " " , ,
, .
:
.
,
. . ,
""
II . ..
, ""
II . ..,
( 600-1300 . ..),
.
,
""
, .
600-1300 . ..
"" , ,
"" .
.. [141] , ,
"" XIV-XVI ...
,
.
..
. , ,
,
, "
". , , ,
, . ,
...
, ,
50",2 , , 50",2
, ,
. : ,
"", XV-XVI .
.., .. ,
"". ,
- , -
- 20
- 10
, II . .. (
"", ). :
"" - , - (
, ).
, , XVI ""
, ;
- , ""
, (XVI ) .
,
( )
. , ""
,
,
.
"".
1) - ,
II .. (
) ""
,
, X-XVI ...
2) ,
( , "") II . ..,
XV-XVI .
3) ""
( ), 1515 . ( ,
: " " ..).
"",
, , , "" -
, X-XVI . .. ,
.., , - .
, , "" ( ,
, . ) - , X-XVI .
.
. [430].
" ?
,
,
.
, ,
, ,
,
,
. ,
,
, ,
, XIII
."
, 28.11.1984 .
:
?
"
" ,
. "
( 1851-1854 . - ..)
,
,
.... 1851-1854 . ...
" [6], .12-13.
, ,
: ""
"".
. ,
18-19
.
. ( "")
, -
, . ,
- .
, .. " ".
18-19 [98].
, "
, "
[98], .55-56.
, "" ,
( )
( !) .
( ..) ""
, .
""
.
,
, . XV
: " (),
, , , (?! -
..)" (. [97], .31).
79 ...
: " XV
" [97], .31. ,
, " ",
1748 (
1711 ) [97], .31-32.
. "
, ...
- ,
... -
,
...
, " [108], .224-225.
, ""
.
.
XX
:
200-300 , .. ,
, - ,
. , ,
"", 31 1981 .
" .
().
. .
().
, ,
, ,
".
" ",
, "
" .
: ,
,
.
15.1.
,
, .
. ,
. ,
,
.
,
.
. ,
,
. , ,
,
. -
.
,
. "
... ,
.
300-400 ...
.
...
, , " [157], .103.
(
, ) [157], .103,
" ". ,
:
, , ,
.. ..,
[157], .100-101. ,
[157], .103,
.
,
.
, , , .
, 1994
. . .3, 4.
. . (). 1994
, Peter
Ian Kuniholm ,
, .
Malcolm and Carolyn
Wiener Laboratory for Aegean and Near Eastern Dendrochronology,
Cornell University, Ithaca, New York, USA.
. 4
,
: , , , , , .
,
1000 . ,
.
" " ,
,
.
. , -
"" "".
,
- "
". , "" ,
"
". .
"" .
""
, , . ,
, .
,
.
15.2. , -
- .
.
. : " ,
( -
..),
, , , 3
. , 1800
( - ..),
35- ,
, ,
216 ...
,
...
... ,
, . ,
,
. ,
,
?" [157], .34-35.
. .
.: "
, , ,
. ,
- .
, ( -
- ..),
II 3000 . ,
, .
,
.
3 .
" [157], .39.
. " 300
- - .
,
4-10 " [157],
.70. , ,
.
16. ?
,
.
, ,
., " .
, ,
. ,
. ,
. ,
,
, , , ,
.
?
, ,
,
.
,
" [157], .103.
.. ( )
,
, .
, ,
1000 - 2000
""
,
, "" [99], .94-95.
. ,
..
. : "
.
(! - ..),
,
, (, ,
, -
..), " [123], .24.
,
,
, , "
". (
), - , :
, , ..
(), " , - , - ,
, !
,... ... (..
2563-2423 . .., - 4 - ..). ,
" [123], .24.
, "" :
[123], .24,
.
" (
- ..) ,
, , ,
...
,
, .. (! - ..)
" [99], .104.
( )
,
("" ), -
. ,
.
.. : "
, 3700 ,
(
,
- ..)...
( - ..)
3750 , , ,
" [123], .24-25.
,
, ( ) (
) .
" ,
, ,
,
" [123], .29. ,
- (
2-3 "" )?
, .
. 1-2
(.).
" ", 1984, .3, .9,
,
: "
(!) ,
600 1800 .
, -
, 4000 .
, ...
,
, .
, ."
, ..,
" .
... ...
(, ,
? - ..)... ,
...
...
, ...
...
-
,
.
13,8,
(15,3),
( ) -
1200 !
( 14,7) "" 360 ...
, 16,31, "
" - 600 .
, 17,4
, "" 1080 ...
, ,
.
:
... , ,
, !... ()
6054 (- 415) 6595
(- 500) . .., - 8610 (- 610)
. .. ...
2556 !
..." [99], .94-95.
, ,
,
.
. .
.
1) "",
. "": , 2300 .
"Science", 130, 11
1959 . - .
2) "Nature", 225, 7 1970
, -14
. , 738
. "" "" - ,
7370 . - .
10 ?
3) ""
-14. "" 1300 !
. ,
30 , "" , ,
4600 . - .
"Antarctic Journal of the United States",
6, 1971 .
""
. ,
, ""
, "" .
,
""
.
.. : " , ,
""
"" - ,
"" .
, -
, , , .
( ) -
, !
,
, ..
. , ""
-
- .
, ,
( - ..),
"-" ,
,
,
" [99], .94-95.
- :
.
1988
-
. ,
(I ..),
.. , , .
:
XI-XIII .. ? :
- ,
,
- ,
I- .., XI-XIII .. (
- ?).
,
,
.
.
,
(
!),
.
-
.
.
,
( ). ,
,
. ,
- ,
.
:
. -
,
, ,
.
(.. ),
: , , ..
- ,
(, ..). (
), .
, .
, ,
, .
" - ..
, .
" ( )
, 1972 .
[362].
.
( , ")
,
,
. " .
"
. [315]. . 5.
.: " ...
" 700 (.. - ..)
1300 ... ,
" " " ...
", - ,
" [362], .114.
. " ,
-" [315]
,
".
.: " , ,
, " ,
,
2000 . 800 [362], .
115.
: V . ( )
", X . " ,
V-X . ".
,
,
" " " .. [141],
.
" ,
" ,
, , ,
" ,
. . .. [374] [416].
.
"
. "
: ,
-? :
,
,
, ?
[141] :
,
. .. [141] ,
,
,
( ) , ,
,
.
, , ,
" " ,
, (
) ,
, ,
. ,
, .. ,
:
1) , ,
: ;
,
,
;
2) , ;
( - ).
, 2-
, 1000 .
.. 400 . .., (
) ,
500 - 1600 . .. , ,
300 - 1800 . .. ,
.. 500 - 1600 .
.., , .
, [141],
400 - 1600 .
.. , , [141]
, , 400 -
900 . .. ,
,
(, ) 900 - 1700
. .. 900 . .., 400
..., [141],
, [265],
, 1300 . ..
- .
, "
" ( ), "".
"" () (. [265],
.176-179, NN 6,8,9; - "": II, 28; VII, 50; IV, 52).
:
1)
: 15 30 ,
30 42 .
2) .
3) .
4) .
5) 1- 2- 7 .
6) 2- 3- 11 .
7) .
8) ( ), .. =12".
9) - ( ).
10) - .
11) .
12) . ,
12 .
[265] : 431, 424 413-
.. ,
, .. 431 . ..
( 8), 10" (
) [265],
.176-177.
431 . ..
12" (, , , ,
, .) [265].
. :
" , ,
, 10" ..., "
[265], .176. , ,
17 .
, - 18 . , 9 -
"" - .
[265].
600-200 . ..
, ,
(. ).
900 . .. - 1700 . ..
. .. [141],
.4, .509, ..
.
:
1133 . .., 2/VIII;
1140 . .., 20/III;
1151 ..., 28/VIII.
:
1039 ..., 22/VIII;
1046 . .., 9/IV;
1057 . .., 15/IX. 12.
- .
, , "" .
(XXXVII, 4,4), 190 . .. 188 .
.., .,
900 . .. 1600 . ..: 967 . .. (. [141]).
, , . (",
LIV, 36,1) 188 . ..,
:
415 ... 4/IX 5/IX (),
955 ... 4/IX 5/IX,
1020 ... 4/IX 5/IX.
.
"" .
" " .
"
, .
" " ,
"" ,
(
). , ,
" 400-1990 . .. .
" . 6.
.
900-1900 . .. " ,
. ,
,
.
", 900-1900 .
.., 900 400 . ..,
,
,
. , 400 . ..,
.
,
,
,
".
" " [141]
.. "". 5 ;
; 12 .
.
- .
-
, ,
,
. , ,
. , ,
.
(
).
, , , ,
,
. ,
,
, , " "
,
.
[141]
,
. .
[141],
.6, .664-665, .133, .135, .672-673.
" " ,
, (, , , , ).
30 . .. 14-37 . .. ,
. - . :
568 540 . .. (
.. [141], .6), :
1394 1422 . .. ( 1992 .
- .. ..).
1857 . . ,
[141], .6, .696, .139. ,
..
I . .. ..
. ,
: 1682 . ..
( .. !).
1901 . ..
,
, ,
[141].
, :
1049 . .. ( ),
1065 . .. ( ).
15 . ,
, ,
. [141] ,
, , .
,
,
, .. ,
,
, ,
.
-, , ,
, [176]. , ,
, ,
. ..: "
(.. I . .. - ..)
(..
- ..) " [186], .135.
, ,
.
: 395 . .. 1249 . .. . [141]. 395 .
.. 300 ,
: 1249 . .. -
1100-1150 .
.
... , ()
, 300 .. (
), ,
.
. : 1249 ..
" ". : " -
, 14
1249 " [141],.1,.53.
(, ,
, -, ).
:
, ,
, XIII
.. .
: , ,
- ,
(, , , .).
- : , .
,
( ). "
": 3 33 ..
( ),
. [141].
( ),
, -
. , 200
.. 800 ..
(..). 368 ..
( ).
1600 ..
: 3 1075 ..
"" 700
, .
: 368 1075 .
.. - ,
. ,
X . ..
, - XIII
...
, , ,
, XI 1086 (16
) ,
.
, , . [419]
.. "
? " ?" ".
,
, ,
, , ,
..
,
.
. (
, )
,
.
.
1) -
( .
[374]-[377], - [416]).
2)
;
, .
3)
(. [374]-[377], [416]),
.
4)
(),
[375], [377], [416].
5)
( ).
.
B
-
(, ..), ..
( ) - "" (t),
t. ,
, ( , ..) -
,
t, - "". . .7.
Y (..
) (.8) ,
, ,
. ,
-
- .
, ..
,
(,)
( ) ,
?
,
, (
). ( ) "
" (,). B
" " , , .
(t) - , t
(.9). (t) ,
, .
:
, ()
, - .
B , (t)
.
:
Y,
(,),
,
, , (" ")
,
, - ,
( ). , " "
,
.
.
"" Y, ..
(,) ,
( )
(,), .. , " ", ,
" Y", (.10).
, Y , ..
(,) (C,D) ( ),
, Y
( (,)
(C,D)) (.11).
,
( ) Y, ..
, Y
( ).
.
-
. ,
.
. f(,Y) - f[k], f[]
- "k"
"k" Y.
,
, f[k] .
f(,),
,
f(,Y).
, , (
)
(,Y). ( (,Y) . [416],
[419], [375].) (X,Y) , Y
. , X Y ,
.. .
1978-1980 . ..
(,Y)
(, ..).
( . [416], [419], [375].)
, (,Y)
.
, ,Y,
(
), .. - , (,Y)
1 1/100 (
10 15). , Y , ..
, (,Y) 1/(10
8) ( ).
.12 : -
.. " " (. 1-2, .,
1938, ), Y - " " . (. 1-6,
., 1897-1899). (,Y) = 2/(10 12),
(
). '
, Y' - ,
, , " " (..
), (',Y') = 1/3.
: = ,
Y = [166]. . .13.
"" 850 - 1255 . ..
, . (,Y)
= = 1/(10 24).
:
) ,
) ,
) .
""
:
, ,
- , .. [416], [419],
[375].
,
:
,
.
(
).
Y - ,
. t
- ,
, -
- , .
Y ""
,
, , .
, (,Y) , ..
, (
1/(10 8),
( , (,Y))
.
.
. :
Y - ( ),
327- [166].
" ",
,
, Y (
(,) (C,D)). ..14. (,Y) =
2/(10 25). , -
[166], (,) = (1390-1717 . ..).
Y .
,
.
: ,
(, , ),
,
: ..?
[416], [419], [376], [377].
.
.
.
(
), : -
..
"" ,
, , .
,
. ,
.
( ,
..) ,
,
, ,
. , ,
. [22] [20].
, , , -
(A[1], A[2],...,A[k]), A[p]
( , )
"p", "k" -
. ,
, . ,
, , ,
(B[1],
B[2],... B[k]). , ,
,
. " ".
"" ,
, ..
(
).
, "" (
).
.
, ""
. , ,
(.. )
.
() .
(
) ,
: ,
, ( ) ,
.
, ""
, (,Y). (,,)
. , (,,).
,
, -
. , ""
,
, .
( . [416], [419], [376], [377], [375]).
(,,) , , ""
, .
, :
( , "" ) / (
, ).
,
. ,
. ,
:
.
. 1977-1979 .
( ., .)
[20],
, , , 4000
. .. 1800 . ..
14
.
15- , ..
, 15 .
15- ,
.. "".
: , , ,
, , , , , ,
, , , , , ,
, , , , ,
, , , , ,
, , , . 15-
(,,).
,
:
(,,) 1/(10
12) 1/(10 8),
(,,) 1/10 1/100 (
1/1000). (
) .
, (,,)
.
, " ",
, ,
.
( )
. ,
(,,), -
. ,
, ,
( (,,)), ..
,
( ).
.
[416].
,
, , ,
. ,
,
,
.
- "",
( ,
),
.
, ,
,
.
, ,
"-".
, "" -
,
.
,
[20].
17,1 .
"-" ,
.
(,),
.
"-" (), -
( ()) "",
.
: ()
"-" ; ,
( ), ? :
"" ?
,
"": =
. .
, ,
( ), ,
,
.
( ). ,
.
, , ,
, .. ,
, .
- (
).
,
"-".
"-" ,
,
, - ,
Q,
( ),
Q
, ;
, ,
, ,
.
: ,
.
,
.
.
( = ),
. ""
, . ,
"-" Q.
Q-,
Q-. ( )
"" K(Q,Q). ,
"" .
K(Q,T). ,
(.. ),
. ,
"", - K(Q,T),
Q - . Q .
.
"-"
K(Q,T) :
Q , Q - ,
(). . . 15.
( . 15) .
.
"" ,
.
[416]. .
1. " " . (., 1887-1889, .1-6).
K(Q,T) "", 750-500
. .. 510-293 . ..,
, .. ,
- ,
,
. ,
, "-"
"" .
2. Liber Pontificalis, (. [47], . .,
Gestorum Pontificum Romanorum, 1898.
, :
1) 300-560 . ..,
2) 560-900 . ..,
3) 900-1250 . ..,
4) 1250-1500 . ..
, K(Q,T) 1-4
a,
.
:
, , "
" ( ). ,
(,
..), , , - ,
""
"" . "" ,
K(Q,T)
, .
3. , 976-1341
. .. ,
:
1) , "" ( 976-1075
.), ., 1987;
2) , "
" (1081-1118), , 1859;
3) , "
" (1118-1180), , 1859;
4) , .1, ",
" (1118-1185), , 1860;
5) , . 2, "
" (1186-1206), , 1862;
6) , "" (1203-1261), , 1863;
7) , " "
(1255-1282), , 1862;
8) , " " (1204-1341), ,
1862).
( ). , K(Q,T)
976-1200 . 1200-1341 .
. .
, ,
.
4. . , " ",
, . 1-6, 1902-1912. ,
:
1) 300-560 . ..,
2) 560-900 . ..,
3) 900-1250 . ..,
4) 1250-1500 . ..
"-",
. ,
""
1-4 .
" " (., .1-2, 1860), ,
:
1) 600-1000 ...,
2) 1000-1273 .,
3) 1273-1700 .
;
.
"-" ( ),
. "-"
- .
"" X(Q) K(Q,T) "".
K(Q,T) ( Q T)
{} n n, n - "".
{} ,
. 16.
16 - ,
- ; (
) , . ,
, .
. 17.
"",
K(Q,T),
" ". , {}
. ""
s {s} ( s -
, s),
"",
, .15, ..
{s} .16.
"",
,
. " "
. . [416].
.
Y, , -
(,), , "-
", "" .
, Y?
,
,
.
: Y "" ,
Y "" - Q,
, "".
"" Y.
, K(Q,T), ,
"",
. , Y
"", .
, Y. ,
, ,
, - " ".
.
1. 500 20 . ..
. , ,
" " (. 1-3, .,
1963-1964). , ,
"-" 400-200 . ..
. Y "" .
319-227 . .. (.
.2,.502,503, .5,89). ""
"", , ""
IV - III . ..
() .
,
"", , ,
"", .
,
, . , ,
.
2. ,
( ):
) Y = Gesta Francorum et aliorum Hierosolymitanorum. -
Histoire anonime de la premie`re croisade. Ed.L. Bre'hier,
Paris, 1924, pp. 194-206.
() 1099 ..
( ): XI .
..;
) Y = Robert de Clari. La conqu^ete de Constantinopole.
Ed.Ph.Lauer. Paris, 1924.
1204 .. : XIII
... ,
.
,
.
(,) , "-" ().
,
, .. "",
, , .
, ""
: Q R. Q R.
.
, K(Q,T) K(R,T) , .18.
,
"" ,
. K(R,T) ,
"" X(R) " " -
X(Q). , .15
,
.
, "", ,
"",
. 18, "", ,
(.. ),
. ,
( ..).
.
" "
1973 (),
. ,
"", .
"-",
{}, "".
, . 19,
, . ,
, -
"".
.
. , :
, 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ,
1 , 2 .
( )
"-".
"-", -
"-".
(.,
, 1968 , , ,
1912 ).
:
(1) = .1-3 (, ),
(2) = 4:1-16 (, ),
(3) = 4:17 ( ...),
(4) = 4:18 ( ...),
(5) = 4:18 ( ...),
(6) = 4:18 ( ...),
(7) = 4:19-24 ( ...),
(8) = 4:25-26 ( []...) +
5:1-6 ( ...),
(9) = 5:7-11 ( ...),
(10) = 5:12-14 ( [170] ...),
(11) = 5:15-17 ( [165] ...),
(12) = 5:18-20 ( ...),
(13) = 5:21-27, (14) = 5:28-31,
(15) = .5:32 + .6 + .7 + .8, (16) = .9, (17) = 10:1,
(18) = 10:2, (19) = 10:3, (20) = 10:4, ............, (48) = 10:32,
(49) = 11:1-9, (50) = 11:10-12, (51) = 11:13-14, (52) = 11:15-16,
(53) = 11:17-19, (54) = 11:20-21, (55) = 11:17-19, (56) = 11:24-25,
(57) = 11:26-27, (58) = 11:28, (59) = 11:29-32, (60) = .12,
(61) = .13, (62) = .14-24, (63) = 25:1-2, (64) = 25:3,
(65) = 25:4, (66) = 25:5-10, (67) = 25:11-18, (68) = 25:19-26,
(69) = 25:27-34, (70) = .26-33, (71) = .34-36, (72) = .37-38,
(73) = .39-50. .
(74) = ,
(75) = ,
(76) = ,
(77) = ,
(78) = ,
(79) = , .1,
(80) = , .2,
.....................................
(96) = , .18,
(97) = , .19-21,
(98) = ,
(99) = ( ), .1-15,
(100) = ( ), .16-31,
(101) = ( ),
(102) = ( ), .1-11,
(103) = ( ), .12,
(104) = ( ), .13,
.........................................................
(112) = ( ), .22,
(113) = ( ), .1,
(114) = ( ), .2,
.........................................................
(135) = ( ), .23,
(136) = ( ), .24-25,
(137) = ( ), .1-10,
(138) = ( ), .11-29,
(139) = ( ), .1-9,
(140) = ( ), .10,
.................................................................
(166) = ( ), .36,
(167) = , (168) = , (169) = ,
(170) = , (171) = , (172) = ,
(173) = , (174) =
, (175) = , (176) = ,
(177) = , (178) = , (179) =
, (180) = , (181) =
, (182) = , (183) = ,
(184) = , (185) = , (186) =
, (187) = , (188) =
, (189) = , (190) =
, (191) = .
.
:
(192) = , (193) = , (194) =
, (195) = , (196) =
, (197) = , (198) = ,
(199) = , (200) = , (201)
= , (202) = , (203) =
, (204) = , (205) =
, (206) =
, (207) = , (208) =
, (209) = , (210) =
, (211) =
(), (212) =
(), (213) = , (214) =
, (215) = , (216) =
, (217) = , (218) =
().
, 191 -,
- 192-218.
170 - (
).
1974-1979 . .. ..
"-".
, 2000 ,
( ) - .
(Q,),
"".
4 ( 2).
, , "" 1-4
, .18, .. ,
"", ""
"" 1-2 .
{} .20.
,
. ,
,
.
.21
.
() .
- ,
, .
,
. ""
, -
.. , ,
, ..
,
: ,
"" ( "").
( ) ,
,
" ".
. . . .
"-".
,
. ""
( ) 20 .
(Q) ,
"" () (.. -
(Q). (Q,Q).
,
(). (Q,).
(Q,) ( 169 ).
K(Q,T) , ,
- . ,
- ,
" ". (
..).
, "-
"
(Q,T) . 15.
, (
), Q,
"" ( ),
"" Q
, .. Q,
Q () Q.
, ,
:
1) , . 1-5,
2) , . 6-10,
3) , . 11,
4) , . 12-38,
5) , . 59-50, + + + +
+ + , . 1-18,
6) . 19-21, + + 1-3 + 4 , . 1-23,
7) 1-2 + + .
, (Q,T)
1-7 .15. ,
( ), , ,
1-7 ""
.
"" ,
,
" " (Q,T). "" (Q) (R) - ,
(Q,T) (R,T) , .18.
: 1-4 1-2 .
(Q,T) ,
"" 1-4 1-2
,
K(Q,T).
. , "
" " ",
"" , , (
), .
.
,
.
(
K(Q,T) (Q,T)) - .
. . ,
() ,
.. , ,
. ,
= []
, " "
: ,,,,,[],
, - .
, ( -
) .
,
( 1-4 1-2 )
. - .
, .
, =
(, .1-3)
(, .4-5)
(, .6-8)
(, .9-10)
(, .11(.1-9))
(, .11(.10-32))
(, .12)
(, .13-38)
(, . 39-50)
() // ( + + + + ,
.1-18)
(, .19-21)
( + 1-2 + 3 , .1-11)
(3 , .12-22, + 4 , .1-23)
(4 , .24)
[] (4 , .25 + + + ).
, [] (
- ) . 1-2 .
- , .
, ,
. "" NN 1-170
{} . : ""
98-137 "" 138-167 - :
, ,
98-137 ,
(. 20 21).
19
. 138-167 .
,
, . . 21
,
.
,
, , :
.
, ,
- "".
, ,
" ",
, ,
.
, - ,
""
.
- 34 ,
:
1) (. ; . ).
2) .
3) .
,
(. ). .
4) (. , ,
; . ; . , ; .
, ..; . (,
..)).
5) (.
; . ;
. ( ); .
; . ,
).
6) (. ; .
; . ; . ; .
;
( ), ).
7) (. ; .
; , - ; . ; . ; .
" ").
8) (. ; . ).
9) = .
10) B[1], ..., B[p] (
: a[k] =
B[k]; c[k,x] = B[k]
B[x]).
11) "" B[k] , "k" (.
; . ; :
).
12) B[k]
(, , , ..).
13) B[k] (. ; .
; . ( , ); .
).
14) (. ; . ; .
).
15) (.
; .
).
16) (. ; . ).
17) (. (); .
).
18) () .
19) .
20) (. ; . ).
21) (. ; . ).
22) .
23) ( ).
24) ( ).
25) .
26) .
27) (.
; . ; .
).
28) ( ).
29) ( ,
).
30) , , .
31) , ..
32) (. ; .
( ); . ; . ,
).
33)
( , , ..).
34) ""
34 "".
-1, -2, ..., -34. ,
"" ,
,
.
- . ,
- .
-, -
.
,
-.
(
):
? ,
(. ).
,
. , -
?
, " " (.
), .
- "" ,
;
- , - ""
.
,
(,,), " -"
"". . [416], [375].
: , -,
, ,
- . ,
- , , .
.
, .
, ..
,
.
-,
(
) , .
. 1979-1980 .
.
,
:
) ( )
(.. "
");
) (,
, )
(..
).
,
..,
.
. ,
Q L(Q,T), L(Q,Q)
, Q, L(Q,T)
, .
, L(Q,T) .15 (
). ,
-
, , .
,
.
, .
,
( X-XI . ..) ,
,
, XVI . ..
( , XVII .).
" "
.
, , XVI . ..
. 1522 .,
(. )
, : -
,
, ,
,
, ..
, ,
,
. (
) ,
( ) .
, , -
, Gottia (?) - ,
, - Judei, ..
(1598 .) ,
. , , XVII . (.
) .
,
"", , .
.
.
1) "" (. , 1545
., ., , [64], . 97),
, II . .., XV-XVI . .., ..
.
"" (. ).
2) tabula Pentingeriana
(., , [1], .3, .232-233) ..,
, XII-XIV . ..
- .
3) (, ,
, .
[64]): ( VIII . ..), (, VI-V
. ..), (, V . ..), (,
V-IV . ..), (, 276-194 . ..), ""
(, 168-165 . ..), -
' , XIII-XV . ..
1974-1980 .
, , ,
.
[20] 14 (. )
222 (, ..),
,
4000 . ..
1800 . .. .
(, , , ..)
- ,
.
( ) .
. ( )
. - ,
- (, ). (,)
(,D) ( ),
,
.
,
""
( ).
. , ,
,
[416], [374] - [377]. ,
(,Y) ,Y,
. (,)
, , L(Q,T) ,
-.
,
,
(,Y), (,) , ..
, (,
, - ..). .
753-236 . ..
300-816 . .. : (,) 300 816 . ..
, , . "
" (. 1-5, , 1902-1912).
" ".
"" (,D) 1- 517 .
" Y", :
1) " " . (. 1-6, ., 1897-1899)
1- 459 . , ,
.
2) (,D) 459 517 .
,
.. " " (., 1928, ).
p = 2/(10 12). (. .12).
(,Y), - ( ), Y -
( ), : p(,Y) = 6/(10
11). ` =
300 758 . .. Y` =
" " 1- 459 . ,
: (`,Y`) = 6/(10 10).
,
: "" , - ,
(
).
, , "
" . (. . 22)
(,) (,D),
(,Y).
-. .
.
4000
. .. 1800 . .. (. [20] .).
( 15 )
, 3.
,
( ),
(,) , ,
.. 1/(10 12) 1/(10 8).
.
,
. -
;
- .
, ,
- - .
, ,
.. - , ,
, , ..
, (
).
; ,
, ..,
( )
, [377].
:
(,
),
:
. , II
: 1196, 1212, 1215,
1220 . "" (
).
. ,
.
1) = ,
82-83 . .. 217 . ..,
= ,
270 ... 526 . .. (, ) =
1/(10 12),
333 . . .23.
2) = 922-724 . .. (
, 1-4 . ),
= , 300-476 . .. (, )
= 1,3/(10 12). . .22.
3) = 928-582 . .. (
, 1-4 . ),
= , 300-552 . ..
(, ) = 1,4/(10 12). . .25.
1-3, ,
, [141],
( N 3) ,
[141] .
, , [141],
( (,)), , ..
" " .
, " "
.
,
.
, ,
, (. ),
.
4) = 140-314 . ..,
= 324-532 ... (,) =
8,66/(10 8). N 1.
. .26.
5) =
, .. 681-887 ...;
= 324-527 . ..
(,) = 8,25/(10 9). . .27,28.
6) = 983-1266 . ..
= 270-553 . .. (,) =
2,3/(10 10).
720 . . .29,30.
7) = 911-1254 . ..
= - 1273-1637 ... (!).
(,) = 1,2/(10 12).
362 ( ).
. .31,32.
8) = 936-1273 . ..
= 82 . .. 217 . ..
(,) = 1,3/(10 12). . .33,34.
9) = 928-587 . .. (,
1-4 . ) (. N 3).
= 911-1307 . .. (!).
(,) = 1/(10 12). . .35,36.
10) = 922-724 . .. (,
1-4 . ),
=
920-1170 . .. (!).
(, ) = 1/(10 8). . .37,38.
: , ( ),
().
,
-
X-XIV . .. , , - XIV-XVI
. ,
[141],
.
(. [416]).
, ,
1250-1460 . ..
510-300 . .. . [433].
()
, (,) ,
, .. 1/(10 8) 1/(10
12).
, ,
, ,
(,Y).
:
,
.. ,
. , ,
(,Y), (,), ,
- . ,
, ,
[141]
"" .
1600 . .. 1700 . .. : ,
, . ,
,
, .. , , -
[416], [374]-[377], ..
"".
. - .
- ("").
, - ,
(),
. :
=
. . 39, .
( " " )
-
.
(=) [1], [2], [3], [4],
:
[4]
1778 C[3]
1053 C[2]
333 C[1]
A
. . 39.
C[0]
()
, , , ,
. , : = [1] + [2] + [3] +
[4]. , (
, " "
), . [2]
[1] 333 , [3]
[1] + [2] 1053 ,
, , [4] [1] + [2] + [3]
1778 .
.
, [416]
( ..).
:
" "
" ",
[1]. [2], [3], [4]
[1] ( )
: 333 , 1053 , 1778 ().
, " "
[1] [0],
300 . .. , ,
- [0] ( [1])
960 . .., .. ,
() 960 . .., ""
,
960 . .. ""
. - [0] (),(), ()
, [0]
(), (), (), 920-960 . ..
1974-1980 .
,
( = ), .
- ,
(
), .
( ),
(, ),
"".
: =
( ) = " ".
( ) = , . 1460-1240 .
..
( ) = , . 1236-1226
. ..
( ) =
.
( ) = ( .),
1-2 ,
850-830 . ..,
; .
( ) = , ,
. 760-753 . ..
( / ) = ., . 753-523 . ..
( ) = , ,
, ,
, 522-509 . ..
( / ) = ,
- , ,
, , 509-82 . ..
( ) = , , , , ,
, 82-23 . ..
( / ) = 82-27 . .. 217 . ..,
.. -
, "", -
.
( ) = III ... (235-251 ),
, .. " " ,
, 217-251 . ..
( ) =
, 270-306 . ..
( /// ) = 306 526 . ..
( ) = YI . ..,
, , , ,
535-552 . ..
( // ) = 553-900 . ..
,
, 681-887 . ..
( ) = II II , 931-954 ...
( / ) = , 962-1250 . ..
( ) = XIII . ..,
, ,
, , , 1250-1268 . ..
( ) = - , 1273-1619 . ..,
- ,
,
,
, .
, 330 . ..
( ). ,
, , ,
.. " ". ,
:
1) XIII ..,
2) VI .,
3) -- I ..,
4) VI .. ,
5) XIII .. (
, ,
).
, , ""
, - .
,
(" " )
.
;
: , ..
""
: (..
[1] [0], . ),
,
, .
() "" ,
, - 333 ,
1053 1778 ( ). "
" [1] " " ,
. ,
( - ).
, . .
[416] [418].
" " ,
,
" ". , , ,
. , ,
. .
-, "" .
, , ,
() ,
-- .
:
= ( )
. 39
.
, (= , )
" " , 850 .
.. 1400 . ..
, ( " " )
, :
, 300 ... ,
(
) , ,
960-1500 ...
, , , XI . ..
().
, ,
" " ( ..) " "
- VII (XI . ..). "
" ,
(1054 . ..) ,
.
, ""
. , " XI
.." ,
XI .. , ,
- . . [416],
[429].
(= )
.
,
(,Y) (. ). 800 . ..
1300 ... .
, (,),
: . [145] ( 800 .
.. 552 . ..) . "
" (. 1-5, , 1902-1912), 300 -
1300 . .. ( ).
300-552 . .., ,
(,).
(), "" ()
800 . .. 1300 . .. 2100
.
.
""
. : .
, ,
"-" (),
1 170. 137 "-",
.. 4 . 1-4
1-2 , "" 138-167
"" 98-137 . "" 103-137
3-4 ,
: 341 . (. [416]).
"" 1-102
,
. "" 1-102 , ,
, -
- "", ""
" ".
, 17,1
( ,
), .. 17 .
, , ,
"" 102 , 102
17 = 1734 . , , ,
" " (
), 1734 + 341 = 2075 .
, , 2100 -
, (. ).
"" .
.
, ,
(,) = ( 800 . .. 1300
. ..) 19 , ,
(,) (), .
19 20 : 800 .
.., 770, 750, 520, 380, 100 . .., 14 . .., 98, 235,
305, 493, 552, 715, 901, 1002, 1054, 1250, 1268, 1300.
(,) ( )
, ,
"-",
, 19 :
800-770 . .. ;
(770-750) . .. "-" N 1;
(750-520) - "" 2-14;
(520-509) - "" 15;
(509-380) - "" 16-23;
(380-100) - "" 24-39;
(100 . .. - 14 . ..) - "" 40-46;
(14-98) - "" 47-50;
(98-235) - "" 51-59;
(235-305) - "" 60-62;
(305-493) - "" 63-73;
(493-552) - "" 74-78;
(552-715) - "" 79-88;
(715-901) - "" 89-97;
(901-1002) - "" 98-102, 141, 142;
(1002-1054) - "" 143-147;
(1054-1250) - "" 148-162;
(1250-1268) - "" 163;
(1268-1300) - "" 164-167.
, "" 141-167
"" 103-137. , ()
() ' .
,
19 . , ..
( ) . , ""
2-14, N 1, 59 , -
13 , .. ( )
59/13 = 4,54. . . 40.
() .
, , ,
. , - (),
.40 ,
"" ,
"" 1-137.
. 40 ,
. ,
-
"-" ,
, . -
"" .
[416] (,Y),
.
,
1, 2,... ,19. (,Y) = 1,4/(10
4), ( ,
8). ,
(. [416])
,
. , ,
" ", , ,
.
, ,
( 1-4 1-2
) 962 - 1300 . ..
,
-.
(,), .
, ,
, ,
.
(- -) ,
, .
( , ,
, , )
XIII . .. , : ,
,
,
(" "). 70-
() 70-
(1305-1376 . ..), [20].
, , ,
( , " ")
1376-1410
. .. ( ),
XV-XVI ..
- (),
.
, =
( ) = ;
( ) = , , , , , , ,
, , , ;
( ) = , "", ;
( ) = , , , " ";
( ) = " ", ;
( ) = , , , , , , , ,
;
( ) = , , "" ;
( ) = , , ,
- , , , , ;
( ) = , ,
" ";
( ) = , , ,
;
( // ) = , , "
", "";
( ) = , ;
( ) = , , , ;
( ) = ;
( ) = , ,
, (
" "), ;
( [] ) = , 70- ,
" ".
, . 39,
(.. ) ,
" ".
.
(" " ) :
" ", 900 . ..,
, ""
900-1600 . .. , ,
" " 900 . ..
( , , ) . ,
,
,
- [1], C[2], C[3], C[4].
, " " - ,
,
.
"" ,
III . .. . 900-1300 .
.. , , (. . 39),
- - 1300 .
.. , " ",
900-1300 . .., "" :
, 900-1300 . .. (,
), ,
(1300-1600 .).
XVI - XVII
., ( )
, "" "
" (. "" , . 39). -
, , ,
,
C[2], C[3], C[4], C[1].
1300-1900 . ..
,
1300-1900 . ""
C[1] ( C[0])
, , ,
,
.
.
:
1) " ",
2) " "?
-, " " (.. ,
) X-XI
. .. ( ); X .
, 300-1000 . ..
, " " X ...,
X-XVI . ..
( ) X-XVI . ..
.. ,
. , ..,
III-V . .. (
),
X-XVI . ..,
, ...
,
, -
. , ,
,
.
: "" .
[141] , , ,
, (
, . )
VII-XIII . .. VII-XVI . .. (
).
. . 39.
1053 + 333 = 1386
XVI . .. 1524-1547 . ..
( : 138-161 . .. [20]).
, " "
. 1537 .,
1538 ., "" 1528 .
" ", .
,
, .
.
I-III . .. X-XIII . ..
(. )
"". ,
- XVI . - ""
I (1440-1519).
,
.
, , :
(. . 41).
(
) (. 1).
11.1.
,
XV-XVII ..
.
(. 11.4
[419]). ,
( ) .
XI ..
( .33) I ..
,
" ".
X-XVII .., ,
.
11.2. .
, ,
- ()
.
(-, XIV-XVI . ..)
,
(), ,
"" .
, ,
- (),
.
, ,
:
? ,
, : "
" (., , "" ).
" " ().
= (
) . ( ) "
" - , 753 .., .. ,
( ) 330
.. -
,
.
, "
". "" 753 ..
. "" -
( ) "" 330 .. ( ,
, ). (, ,
,
, , ).
: . ,
I 330 . ..
, 330 . ..
" " [56], .26.
[56], .26.
, .
, ""
( ),
- ( ).
( )
(,
).
663 . .., -
( I, III), , -,
, [141].
, - .
,
( ).
,
: ,
(. .). .
"" - (, .1,
.1). , - ,
,
, " ",
[218], .18.1.. 170-175. ,
"",
, .
XII-XIV . .. .
, , , , ( )
" , ...
"" (! - ..) ...
, (., "
", ., 1947, .28).
, " "
(, ,
).
, I "
... ...
( - ..) ...
(., , .28). , ""
. " VII
VIII . (! - ..) ...
;
, ...
" (., .31-32).
.. ",
: ,
...
, ...
"" ...
( ! - ..)
(?! - ..)
... ( - ..) ...
.... " [46], .51.
.
,
, (
, ), XI
( 330 ..). , 330
360 , .. - XIV .. (
) .
( XI ..)
XIV ..,
330 ( 360 ).
,
.
" ".
- "
"?
, ,
.
(, , ) .42. "
" ,
-. ,
.42.
" " , "
" X-XVII . .., ,
,
, .. " " -
, , . , "
" :
.
11.3. .
XV-XVI .
,
" ", - . ,
,
-
. , -
" ",
" " . ,
- ,
(!) XVI - XVII .
, , .
- ,
" ". , ,
, 30- ,
.
" ,
" [77], .99.
1514 .
, ,
, .
,
.
. - 532
, ( )
, - . "
,
" [77], .99.
( ),
IV . ..
: 7980 .
"", , , "
,
XVI . " ".
...
(1540-1609) "
" ... 1583 .,
(! - ..) ,
( - ..)
. (
- ..)
, ,
, -
"
[77], .106.
- : " ,
( - ..),
... ,
XIII " [77], .107.
(1545-1563),
, .. , ,
" ".
,
c. "
... " " ...
...
...
" [91], .2,
.107-108.
.,
,
. ,
( , )
,
.
11.4. ,
.
: X.III -: III .
,
,
, - ( ).
:
1)
, .
2) .
3)
- , (
).
4) ( ),
"", .
5) - ,
.
6)
.
. , 1053
( 1000 )
. :
) ; , III
".III", -
(- .). "" -
"", ,
" I " ".I", "
II " - ".II", ..
,
: I ( ), II ( ),
..
"".
"" VII ( 1020 .,
1073 . 1085 .) ""
1053 . . [419] 7 1
. , III III
XI ..., XIII , .. X.III .
,
" :
( ) - XIV , ( ) - XV ,
( ) - XVI " [58], .25.
XI ...,
" ".
, 1300 ()
I.300, . 300- (- .).
, I300 = 300-
= 300 XI ... ( ).
, ,
, ( XIII- XVI
.) (,
, " ")
, .
, , 1527
- Diogo Ribeiro (. "Durer Kunst und
Geometrie", E. Schroder, Berlin, 1980).
, : ). ,
" " ,
(, "III "
"X.III "). ,
"X" "I"
, .
( ):
X - , I - , .. "X.III" "I.300"
" " " ".
1000 ,
("
III " ("X.III ").
, 1000 -
.
" " (. [419]), ,
" " 5508 . ..
- ( =
1 ..), .
: ,
,
, ,
. "="
, ,
.
"=" = (
=1 =2 ..). , ,
"=", "="
,
. ,
" =" .
, =, ,
, ,
" =",
(
), ,
.
5508 . .. ,
" " XI .. ( ""
, XI ),
" ", .. "..".
, ""
(. [419]): 1073 -
[47], 1075 -
[47], .4, .155-156,
, " ".
(
), : 6581=1073+5508
6583=1075+5508. (
, . [227], .150),
=: 6581= S, 6583= S. "",
() =
,
"". ,
I
(). . "I" ""
I.300 , .. 1300 . ,
("", . , ).
=:
6581=IS,
6583=IS.
,
: "
() (.. , )"
( IS - , - (), - , - ,
); " ( )".
"" = . , =
-
"".
5508 . ..
(
) " ", .. ".
.." (. ).
( ),
.
I () [227],
, : "
(.. )" - IS. =1
=2 .., .. = .
,
. =
=, .
, ,
IS 6581.
,
, , - 1073 -
I.073, .. " 73- ".
( ?) "I"
"", " ".
.
, .. IS (=6581) 1.073
(=1073), ,
5508. "", ""
" ..". ,
(.. 5508 . ..) ,
IS=6583 1.075 (.. 1075). ,
, IS + t
1.073 + t, t - ,
VII ( 1073 .). ,
" =".
, ""
" ", [419].
( -
2100 ),
, .. "=".
, , 333
360 (). XV-XVI . .., ..
- I
(1493 - 1519), , , : MCL.III, ..
" III- ".
"" - 1153 ,
343 . , ,
MCL.(...)
, (!) 340 .
,
,
900 . .. ( ), ,
, , X-XVII .
.. : " "
" ", . . ,
" "
" "
? , ,
. -, ,
(., ,
, 3) .
-,
,
" ". " "
.
XVIII-XIX .
, " ".
"
", " ",
[90], .161).
, () ,
, ,
"" .
[90],
.166. "" ( ,
..) .
( VI ..),
, ,
- , ,
, ,
. - ,
. - .
, ,
, " "
[90], .167. .
,
,
, , : "
VI-VII
" [90], .169.
, "
", ,
- ,
, " "
.
, ,
,
, ,
.
(c. ).
. ""
, " " (!).
, . :
(..
) 400-500.
, ,
, .
[47].
" , (, VI ...-
..),
. , , -
" [47], .2, .3-4.
(, "" )
.
" ".
" " (, - ,
) " " "
" [47], .2,
.3-6.
(
) . , VI . ..,
. ( [47]) :
" ,
, , ,
" [47], .2, .21.
IX : "
, ,
,
,
.
"[47],.3,.58.
: "
... (
" " - ..), XII XIII ,
,
" [47], .3, .121.
- ,
, XI ..
" ... ,
VII X ( ! - ..)
, " [47], .3,
.131, . 30. "
,
. , ...
;
, ,
,
" [47], .3, .125-126.
, "
" ( , .125-126).
, ,
. "
I ( IX .. - ..)
,
"
( , .127).
"
" .
" ", "",
" " .. : " X
, .
, "
[47], .3, .316.
.
, ( "")
, ,
" " ,
" ". .: " ( -
..) ,
, , ,
(! - ..)
" [47], .3, .349.
" X "
[47], .3, .409, .20. X " ( - ..)
" [47], .3, .388.
,
Graphia, .
: "Graphia o " [47], .3, .458,
.7.
: "
III,
, - , , -
, (
- ..) ...
(! - ..)... X
( , , - ..)
,
V, - ,
... ,
,
.
X , Liber
Pontificalis ,
"( ,.458,427,431).
,
. , , ,
" (! - ..)
; , ,
... , (! -
..) ... " [47], .3,
.437. " (
- ..) " [47], .3, .461, .26.
"" ( )
X-XIII . .. . :
" ,
,
" [47], .3, .443. ,
XII . .. ,
, "
" [47], .3, .447.
: " ( - ..)
., .;
; -
;
; -: ., .,
., . ." [47], .3, .447.
XI-XIII . ..
: " ( "" -
..) ;
( - ..)" [47], . 3, .447-448.
,
"" "" . : "
Hercules Victor,
; , (?
- ..), , ,
, -
" [47], .3, .469-470. ,
.
" ... 500
( . - ..) ...
,
, (! -
..) ,
. XI
( ? -
,
" "
: [47], .4 -
..) ... ,
(! - ..) ...
, ,
II
. ,
( ? -
..), , IV, ...
. , ,
( ? - ..)" [47], .3,
.491.
, ,
, ,
- .
, ,
, , , , (
), ,
.. ..
, ,
,
,
XIII-XVI " ".
( - , ""
),
, -,
, :
"
, ,
, , -
" [47], .4, .391-392.
, ,
: ",
,
,
, ... , ,
!... (, , -
- ..) ,
" ",...
, "" (
? - ..)..."[47],.4,.393-394.
-
XII .. ,
,
() - ,
. ,
.. , ,
.
X-XI , :
", : ,
,
, , ,
, ." XII : "
( - ..) ."(
,.412,415). , "" (
) . , XII
III "
" ( , .503).
"
,
, ... XIII ...
; ,
.
S.P.Q.R." [47], .4, .573 .5, .126-127.
" ", ""
, , ..
( ).
.
,
XII-XIII ( , .544-545).
,
, .
, (!) (
[416]). ,
. , , ""
III ( XI ) [47], .4, .568,
.74. : "
..." [47], .4, .568, .74.
? : " ,
,
?" [47], .4, .573.
,
,
. " .
, . , ,
, ...
... (!? -
..). ,
" " ""
." (. "", 1980, 16 ).
:
, ..,
,
" ",
.
XIII , , ,
. ,
, " ".
, , XIII
, ,
"" ( ),
. ,
: "
13 ."(.5,
.510).
, ( 1256 )
" (! - ..) ,
, -
!"
, ,
? -
. ,
,
", .. ".
. "
, - , -
;
... ,
" [47], .5, .511.
? ,
! ,
.
: "
... ... , ( ! -
..) , ; , (! -
..), ...
, (? - ..)
."[47], .5, .526-527.
,
, , ,
-
- ! " ,
" ( ).
, - (
), " "
,
.
- .
"" .
. ,
, .
.
-. ,
- ,
(
). ..
( , ), .. -
" ", . -,
,
, (
). -
, ,
. ,
. .
, .
?
, , (.
[141]):
1) 6
;
2) 6 ;
3) ;
4)
12 20 ;
5) ;
6) ,
;
7) ,
;
8) , ,
.
- .
( ) ,
.
, , .
" ,
? , ,
. , ,
, , ,
,
..."
, I .. 142
( 144 !) .
, , .
!
,
I .. [194], .2,.203,211.
- "".
,
XIV-XV ..
.
" XI-XIII
,
... XIV .
( 1331-1334 .)
... ... ... ...
,
...
"" ""
. 1475 .,
, , -, -
. 20- XV
.
- ,
,
. 1425 .
,
,
... - ,
- , .
1455 . , ,
" [194]..2,.241.
:
1) I ..
2) "" .
3)
""
XIV XV ..
4) XIV .. ""
. ,
,
X-XIV ...
.
.
[194]
, .
-
XV ..
,
, .
,
, .
- XV .
C [280], [337], [9],
"" .
[280] [337]
XIX , ""
XV ..
. ,
.
. , , -
,
. (., ,
[194]).
.
, , ,
, , ""
- .
, ""
, - ,
.
,
. . ,
"" . -
.
-,
"".
XIV-XV ..
"" - ,
X-XIV ..
- ""
"" .
XV . -
. " ...
,
- " [9],.358-363. -
" " - .
"
.
...
XV "
"... ,
" [9],.358-363.
...
.
,
. XV ...
. , ...
(1363-1437)...
,
, - ...
... ,
- , "
",
:
,
,
,
,
.
, -
" [9],.363-366.
"
" "" .
.
,
. ,
,
.
" ' (1200 )
., - ...
, , ',
, , , ,
, , ,
... ,
" [9],.363-366.
.
-
- , ,
- . ,
,
.
1470
, ,
, .. " ,
, " [9],.366-368.
" ... ,
" [9],.366-368.
,
55-57 .. " "
[194], .2, .203,211. , ,
I ..
.
XV . ,
, ,
,
"". , ,
- "" - XV
!
" "?
" 1425
, " "
... " ,
" " [9],.382.
.
- . "
...
, ,
... -
: - , , ,
- ... ,
.." [9],.382.
""
. , "
"!
" ,
, 1427 1428 ". , 1428
,
, - !
" ,
, ,
. ,
: " , ...
, ,
". - , -
, -
- ,
, . , ,
..." [9],.374-382.
, "
,
1425-1429 , -
28 1427 5 1428
" [9],.374-382.
(!?)
, .
, ,
" " ,
, , , !
, " , post
factum ,
... (
- .),
, " [9],.374-382.
,
.
( ) :
"
( - .)... ,
, 80
... , -
, . -
X "".
, .
, , . ,
( - .), ...
... ...
, X -
- 500 , ..
6000 , - (
! - .). ,
, , -
,
. ,
,
- .., -
- ,
,
" [9],.374-382.
.
,
.
" ( XVIII - .),
X ,
, . ,
? ( - .). ,
.
, ,
- :
"
[9],.374-382.
,
.
- . " - !
- XV ...
, - , , ;
, " [9],.385.
( )
. "
...
( ? - .),
( -
.), ,
XV " [9],.387-390.
- .
, ,
"" .
,
.
. :
"" X-XIV ..
- XIII-XIV XV
" XV ".
"" ""
,
.
,
""
. . -
"". ,
"" - ?
,
X-XIII .., -
. .
" ( - .) ,
... 1422 ...
- ,
,
,
500 . " -
!" - , .
", , , ,
, , ".
: " , ...
, - ,
... ,
. ,
, ". ... " ,
... , ...
, .
, ..."
- . , ,
- . , .
,
. ,
,
... ,
, -
? :
- .
, ,
.
...
, . ,
, , , ,
, - ,
, , - " [9],.393 .
,
.
" . ".
", "",
,
, . ,
... , ...
,
. ...
... ,
' -
- :
,
. ,
- . ,
,
... . ,
- ... ,
, ,
... , -
, , , -
.
,
, .." [9],.394 .
, ,
. ,
,
, "
".
.
. , ,
- , ,
.
-
:
,
, ,
,
,
,
,
,
.
. 1455 "
' - ( ,
) " ", "
" "", , ,
"" ""...
"Facetiae", ,
" [9],.350-351.
-
, .
X-XIII ..
,
.
-
? , , "
. ( XXIII)". , ,
1980.
"
,
...
,
... , -
, - -...
. :
" , ."
.
, .
,
. (
)
, ... ,
, ,
(. Rodocanachi (E.), La femme Italienne,
avant, pendant et apres la Renaissance, Paris, 1922).
(Polnitz Charles Louis) ,
, ,
, ,
.
. ,
, ,
, " " (. Pizzichi,
Viaggio per l'alta Italia, Firenze, 1820).
,
...
.
: "
,
, ..."[428],
.160-162.
- XIV-XVI
- : "
, ,
.
,
"" ...
, ,
. : "
", " ", " ",
" ", " " (. Frati (Lodov.), La
vita privata di Bologna nel Medio Evo, Firenze, 1898)...
(Pontano Giovanni) ,
,
. ,
(Masuccio Cuardato Tom), ,
" " 1565
,
"(.162-164).
.
: -
XIII-XIV ..?
? , XIV-XVI "
".
,
, .
,
, ",
, ". ,
, , ,
(
). , " "
,
. ,
. .
-, -
"", .
-
. , ,
( "" -
" ", " "
, ). ,
( );
. , ,
.
" " "" -
, (
XIV-XVI ) " ".
, , (
)
-- "",
( ) -
- .
,
. , ,
" " (. [141]).
, , ,
.
: " (
- ..)
.
,
,
.
, " (
[141], .5, .656.
, ,
(!), " "
XIV . ( !), N 166
. "",
- , - ?
- ;
,
.
:
,
, .
""
. , II, ,
(
) "" [125], .156.
" ",
(
"").
, ,
,
. ,
"" . , ,
? ,
. ,
"", -
. !
( )
,
- , ,
;
, ,
, - , -
- , ,
, .
, " ": ,
, , ..
(,
).
, , VII . ..
.
,
.
: " 1212
" " ...
, , ,
" ( [141],
.5, . 658). , 1245
, , ,
.
1284 1559 . .. VI 1430 .
" ".
, ( )
, ,
. " , - , -
,
, ,
,
- ... , ,
,
?" ( [141], .5,
.661).
,
. ,
.
, ,
?
( !) , "",
, , , ,
- . : "
, ,
,
? ,
, ? ...
,
,
. ,
... - ,
( - ..)
, .
-
,
, "
(. [141], .5, .661).
.. : "
. ,
, ,
.
,
" [141], .5, .661.
, (
),
.
"", , , [97].
- ""
.
, " , -
- ,
( - ..), - ...
- ... ...
,
,
" [97], .76. ,
[97], .76.
- . "
... "
[97],.122. . ,
" " (?)
[97], .122. -
, Notre Dame de Paris XII .,
.. ..
[47],
,
, " " ,
" "
, ("
") . -,
( XIV-XV ..) "",
- , ,
XV-XVI .,
- , -
- "" .
- (
), .
, ""
, - ,
,
.
: " ,
( - .. )
,
, , ,
VI X
, .
,
-
,
,
,
" [46], .41.
XIX . -
"" ( ),
, - " "
[46], .41. ,
"," [46].
" VII
, ...
, , ,
. ,
" [46], .42.
" ( - ..) , ,
,
" [46], .2-3. " (..
- ..) ,
" [46], .22. "
" [46], .22.
""
! "
-
... ( X . - ..)
( - ..),
(.. ! - ..)" [46], .24. :
" "" (
- ..); "
",
" [46], .25. ,
=, ,
-.
"
...
,
" [46], .27-28.
" , , ,
... ,
, ...
.
,
. " [46], .29-31.
: "
(
- ..), ...
,
,
....
,
Parthenos" [46], .31.
( )
, "", , VI .
.., , -.
" -" .
" " [46], .36.
"
, .
" [46], .48.
" " ?
" "? ""
- , "", ,
XII-XIII . ? ,
,
. "" ,
, "" [46], . III.
""
: " XV , ,
( - ..)
"" ..." [46], .51.
(
), , ,
-? "
" . ,
X : "
,
-" [46], .54, . 5. :
" ,
"
[46], .54-55.
, , ..
: , ,
, , , .. [46].
XIII-XV . -
, "".
VIII () (!)
, ,
[46], .62-63. ,
, " ,
, ,
- ...
, ,
"
[46], .66.
VIII-X -
. " ,
, .
, , (! -
..) , ,
, ,
"" . , "
[46], .74, 76.
XV " ".
(XII-XIII
.). (
), -
. , " 1600
(! - ..)
[46], .100-101.
"
...
...
( - ..).
" [46],
.101. " , -
, - ,
( .. " " - ..)"
[46], .101.
XII-XIV .
. , ( )
- . ,
. , , [46], .111.
, .
- (. [46]).
,
. ,
.
, (
), : " ( -
..) ,
, " [46], .138.
" , ,
, XIII (
" " - ..) [46], .150.
XII-XIV .
, " ,
...
II ...
" [46], .167,182.
,
.
... , ,
- " "[46].
-, XIII-XV .
" ", e 1453 .
. "
XIV
... ...
, ... ...
1305 . ... ,
,
..." [46], .188(34).
, "
(! - ..) " [46], .204-205.
""
"".
,
, .
2 .
.
( )
, ,
(,
): "
, , ...
...
. ,
,
, ,
, 100 , "
[46], . 188(6). , ,
XIII
...
,
XIX ... .: "
,
250 (XIII-XV . - ..)" (. [141], .4,
.750). XII " "
, " " (. [141],
.4, .805). (!)
" , " (
),
. XIII .
XIII (
) " ",
" ". . (.
[141], .4.)
" II
(), ...
" [46], .308-309.
" ",
[46].
1447 ., .. XV !
. "
" [46], .331.
.
[46], .339,
XV-XVI
. "
,
, ...
...
" [46], .340-342.
"", "
(! - ..), -
.
... ,
(, , ,
"" - ..) ...
1672 . ,
... ... ...
;
- ,
- ,
.
1647 . ...
,
.
.... ... ... ...
, , ... .
- ,
, ...
"" " "; ,
...
...
...
,
, , , ,
, , ... " [46], .340-342.
(
), .
XVI-XVII ...!
1453 . .
, , ,
,
(!) , ,
.. [46].
,
XII-XIII . XIII-XV .,
, "".
XV . ( )
. "
,
. " [46],
.362.
" ...
... 1493 .
: "
. " [46], .364-365.
, XVI . "
: , ?
, ...
... ... . 1573 .
,
, , ,
, , ,
,
.
... ,
;
( ,
, , , ,
,
, V ..
429 . ..; - ,
- ..)" [46], .364 - 366.
XVII (
)
[46], .366. e , " 1835 .
... ,
.
, "
[46], .364-366. "
,
: .
1645 ." [46], .366.
XVII
(!) .
,
,
,
,
.
..,
. ,
, -
, .
, [141],
.
:
,
,
,
. ,
, ( a
, )
(,
" ", "" ..).
, , ,
,
,
. , , "",
e (. ).
,
. :
?
, " ".
(.
11.4, 4, 4), ,
.
(
,
) , , ,
.
.
1) -
. .
, .
2) .
- XI .. I
.. ( ).
3)
.
" - 6":
.., ...
, . (. .
).
" - 8"
.., ... . , , ,
, . .
c .
,
,
. XIX
. , ,
, ""
( ).
, , ..
.
.
.
" ", 1771 ,
[224], .543.
ESUS. ,
, , - "
".
. : " ... ... o
...
-- ..,
, "
" ,
... ,
, ,
- , , ... ...
- "" , " " ,
, , , , ()
...." - "
( )" [224], .150.
. ,
" " " "
, , , ..
. , ,
,
.
, "
(! - ..), ... -
"-". "" ( - )
, " "
" [67], .69.
, , : ,
, , ..
. :
, , (
, ), .. [67].
,
.
,
" ,
... , ,
,
" [67], .71.
,
-- ,
. : "
,
" [67], .72.
" " .
,
, .
[67].
, . : "
,
, , ,
.. , ,
, ,
, - ,
- . ,
...
,
P.X., .
, ,
, .
, , , . - ,
, , -
() ,
...
, , .
, , ,
" [183], .44-45.
,
. ,
"", ,
- , " "
, , ..
, ,
, ""
.
, .
, , . . :
" ,
,
( 1968 -
..).
" [107], .5.
, .
. : "
...
, , .
, - , -
. , ,
, (.. VIII .
.. - ..) ,
, ...
,
" [107], .20.
,
(!). , .. ""
" ", ""
[107].
XI ..!
, . "
...
... ...
... ,
...
,
" [107], .180. ,
.
.
.
, (
, ) : -1,
-2 ..
- 1 (.)
...
. (
, ,
).
, - , 1990 , 440 .
, -
,
.
.., .
- 2 (.)
... . (
.
. ).
, - - - , 1993 .
408 .
,
IX-XVI
.. ,
. ,
.., -
.., .. "
- 1".
- 3 (.)
A.T.Fomenko, V.V.Kalashnikov, G.V.Nosovski. GEOMETRICAL AND
STATISTICAL METHODS OF ANALYSIS OF STAR CONFIGURATIONS. DATING OF
PTOLEMY'S ALMAGEST.
CRC-Press, USA, 1993, 300 p.
- 1995
" ", , - "".
.
"".
, "" -
600-1300 .., ..,
.
- 4 (.)
A.T.Fomenko. EMPIRICO-STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF NARRATIVE
MATERIAL AND ITS APPLICATIONS TO HISTORICAL DATING.
Volume 1. The Development of the Statistical Tools.
Volume 2. The Analysis of Ancient and Medieval Records.
Kluwer Academic Publishers. The Netherlands. 1994.
1 - 212 .
2 - 460 .
- .
,
- .
- 5 (.)
...
( ?). .
, - - .
1993, 204 .
,
" ".
- 6 (.)
.., ...
, . (. .
).
1. . 382 .
2. , . 290 .
, 1995, - -
.
. ,
- - .
- 7 (.)
..
. .
:
1) ,
2) , - , ,
.
- 8 (.)
.., ..
. , , , , .
.
. ""
.
1. . . - .-., - ,
1953.
2. .. . - ,
1876-1877.
3. .
XV . .-., , 1966.
4. . . . .
, . -
, 1892.
5. .. ( .) - ., , 1977.
6. .., .. . - .,
, 1963.
7. .. . - ., , 1960.
8. . 8 ., .4. - ,
, 1911.
9. . ? ! - "
", 1983, N 8. - .28-30.
10. . . - ., , 1965.
11. . .
- ., 1859.
12. . . - ., , 1972.
13. . ; .
. - .-., , 1965.
14. . . - ., , 1962.
15. . - . - " ", 1983,
N 4. - .24-28.
16. ., . . - ., 1915.
17. . . - .-., , 1946.
18. . - 10- . - ., 1912.
19. . . - , , 1975.
20. . ,
XIX . -
. I,II. - , - . -, 1808-1809.
21. . . - ., ,
1978.
22. . . - , 1880. (
. .)
23. .. .
- ., , 1975.
24. . .
. - .1. - ., 1915.
25. ..
. -
. - ., , 1965. - . 35-45.
26. .. . ,
(1261-1453). - ., Academia, 1925.
27. . . - ., 1892.
28. . . - ., , 1975.
29. . - ., - . ., 1962.
30. . , , , ,
, , , , . -
., 1858.
31. . - ., , 1972.
32. .. . - . -
, 1988.
33. . - "" - 1977. - 18 .
34. .. (1854-
1946). - . . . . . - 1947. - N 5.
35. .. ,
. - "", 1947, N 11.
36. . . - ., - . ., 1972.
37. .
. - ., 1863.
38. . .
. - ., 1862.
39. . . - ., , 1972.
40. - ..
. - ., , 1972.
41. .., .. "
" . -
" ", 1982, N 1. - .171-195.
42. .., .. "
". - " ", 1982, N 8.
43. .., .. " "
. - " ", 1983, N 12. -
.68-83.
44. . . . ... - ., . ., 1969.
45. .. . - ., , 1959.
46. . . - , 1900.
47. . . V XVI
. - . 1-5. - , 1902-1912.
48. . . - .,
1877.
49. . .
. - " ". - 1968. -
N 6. - . 23-27.
50. .. . - .,
, 1938.
51. .. . - .,
, 1972.
52. . . - " ". - 1968. -
N 6. - . 16-18,34.
53. . . - ., , 1968.
54. X . ;
. . - ., - . ., 1962.
55. .. - . - ., . ., 1976.
56. . ( ). -
., 1919.
57. .. . - ., , 1933.
58. .. . - ., , 1935.
59. . . - ., , 1975.
60. . . - ., , 1948.
61. . . - .-., -, 1934.
62. . . - ., , 1974.
63. . . - ., , 1963.
64. .. . - ., , 1980.
65. . . .., ... - .,
1956.
66. . . .2. - ., , 1924.
67. . ? - ., , 1924.
68. . . - , 1848.
69. .
, .
. . .. - , 1894.
70. .. .
. - . 1-2. - ., . - .-.
. . . . , 1916.
71. .., .. ""
. - , 1987, .294, N 2,
.310-313.
72. .., ..
"" .
( ). -
- . - ., , 1989. -
.175-192.
73. . - . - .,
, 1988.
74. , ,
, . - ., 1958.
75. . - , . . . ,
1987.
76. . . - ., , 1968.
77. .. .
- "". - ., 1978.
78. . . - . I-IV. - , 1905-1922.
79. . : . - "
", 1982, N 5. - .25-29.
80. .. . - ., - , 1963.
81. . . - ., ,
1925.
82. . . - ., 1862.
83. .
. - ., 1893.
84. .
. - ., 1859.
85. - . - .1. - .-., 1948.
86. . - ., 1858.
87. . - . I. - ., , 1967.
88. . . ... - ., 1979.
89. . . .., ... -
., 1971.
90. . . . .., ..,
... - ., , 1941.
91. , .1-2. . . ... - .,
1977.
92. . ( .) - , 1887.
93. .. I-V. - ., . .
. , 1907.
94. .. . - .,
1962.
95. ..
XI - XII . - ., , 1974.
96. .. . - ., -
. -, 1969.
97. .
. - ., 1848.
98. .. . - "", 1966, N 2,
. 51-62.
99. .. (). -
"", 1966, N 3, . 94-107.
100. .. . - ., , 1985.
101. .. . - ., , 1987.
102. ..
. - " ", 1984, N 9. -
.61-73.
103. .., .. . -
. - ., ,
1972.
104. . . - . I,II. - ., 1860.
105. 1978. - ., , 1978.
106. . - ., - . ., 1963.
107. . . - .,
, 1968.
108. . . - ., , 1968.
109. . - .1. - ., . .
- ". .", 1960.
110. .. "" . - ., .
, 1965.
111. . . - ., , 1935.
112. .. . - ., , 1982.
113. .. . - ., 1922.
113. .. . - ., , 1984.
114. " ". - 1968. - N 12.
115. . "". - , , 1971.
116. ., . . - . I,II. -
., 1914.
117. . . - ., 1930.
118. .-. . - ., , 1966.
119. .. . - .-., , 1940.
120. . - ., , 1978.
120..
. - ., "
", 1900.
121. .. . - ., - ,
1958.
122. " ", . - ., , 1977.
123. .. -14 - . -
" ", 1968, N 7 (N 139).
124. . . - .1-6. - .,
1897-1899.
125. .. . - . I,II. - ., ,
1934.
126. . - .
., . .. - ., 1846.
127. . . - ., - .
-, 1903.
128. .. . - ., ,
1979.
129. . .
... - , . .., 1908.
130. . . . . .., - .1-8. -
, 1955-1971.
131. . . - ., . ., 1974.
132.
: . - ., , 1978.
133. .
3- 1976 . - .,
- , 1976.
134. . . - ., , 1978.
135. .. . - ., , 1954.
136. . . - "
", 1983, N 8. - .31-32.
137. . . - ., 1936.
138. . . - . 3. - ., , 1941.
139. .. .
. - ., 1910.
140. .. ,
. . - ., 1914.
141. .. . ( -
) . 1-7. - .-., , 1924-1932 .
142. .. . -
" ", 1925, N 4, . 133-143. ( .
...)
143. . . - .,
1866.
144. . . - ., , 1968.
145. . . - , 1908.
146. . ,
. - ., 1860.
147. .
(1186-1206). - " ", . 5. - .,
1862.
148. . ,
. - ., 1862.
149. . , . - "
", 1983, N 9. - .29-36.
150. . . - .,
, 1981.
151. , -. -
. - ., , 1982.
152. . . -
, 1944, NN 7,8.
153. ..
. - " ". 1925, N 1, . 157-175. (
. "". ., 1924.)
154. .. . - ., , 1974.
155. .. .. . -
"", 1954, N 10.
156. . . - ., , 1985.
157. . . - ., , 1975.
158. .. . . - ,
1927.
159. . - , 1581. - ( :
., 1989.)
160. . , II
.. - ., 1889.
160. . ".
". - ., , 1979.
161. . . - .3. - ., , 1972.
162. . . - .I. - ., -
, 1961; .II. - ., - , 1963; .III. - .,
, 1964.
163. .. . - ., , 1938.
164. . 40 . - ., 1899.
165. . - .33. - ., , 1977.
166. . - .35. - ., , 1980.
167. .. ? - "
", 1982, N 7. - .28-33.
168. .. X-XIII . -
., . , 1968.
169. . . - ., , 1952.
170. . . -
. - 1939. - N 4. - . 201-298.
171. . . - ., - , 1950.
172. . - , 1657.
173. .. . - ., , 1974.
174. . - "", 1990, N 3. -
.117. (New Scientist. 1989. Vol. 123, No. 1684. P.26.)
175. . . - ., - . -,
1903.
176. . . - , 1907.
177. . ? - " ", 1983, N 9. -
.84.
178. .., .. . - .,
1925.
179. . .. - . -
, . 49, . 1, 1953.
180. .. . - ., , 1930.
181. : . - ., , 1975.
182. ..
. - . . - . ..,
.10. - ., 1924.
183. . . - ., , 1930.
184. .. . - ., , 1936.
185. . . - ., ,
1966.
186. .. . - ,
. . - " ", 1925.
187. .. . - .-., , 1934.
188. .. . - . 1,2. - .,
, 1938.
189. . - .,
, 1979.
190. . . - .6. - ., 1898.
191. . ... - " ", 1983,
N 4. - .28-32.
192. .. . - ., 1907.
193. .. - (
). - ., 1913.
194. . , . I, II. - ., , 1969.
195. . -
. - . 69. - ., - . . .,
1915.
196. . - ., 1904.
197. , . -
. - . 31-33. - ., - .
. ., 1858-1859.
198. . -
. - . 34-36. - ., - .
. ., 1859-1860.
198. .
. .1-12.
.., , 1904-1913. ( -
, , 1987.)
199. -. . -
, 1912.
200. .. . - ., ,
1947.
201. .
XVI XVII . - ., , 1972.
202. .. . - ., , 1936.
203. .. ... - ,
. 16, . 3, 1947.
204. ..
. - , 1962, N 9. - .64-70.
205. .. ,
. - "", 1947, N 11.
206. ..
(1854-1946). - . ,
1947, N 5.
207. .. . - ., - . -,
1969.
208. .. . - ., - . -,
1976.
209. .. . - ., - .
-, 1979.
210. : . . -
, . ... - .I. - ., 1914.
211. . . . I,II. - .,
1885.
212.
. - ., 1779.
213. . . - ., , 1924.
214. . . - . 1. - .-., , 1931.
215. . . - . 3,4. - ., , 1928.
216. . . - .-., , 1931.
217. . . - . 1,2. - ., 1887-
1888.
218. ( ). . .
... - , 1911.
219. 1680 . - ( .)
220. .. . . . - ., ,
1966.
221. .. . - .,
, 1972.
222. .. , , . - .,
, 1975.
223. .., .. . -
., . ., 1972.
224. --- .. . -
., 1899.
225. .. . - ., ,
1977.
226. .. . - ., 1968 (1- .) -
., , 1976 (2- .).
227. .. . - ., , 1967.
228. .. . - ., , 1963.
229. . . . . -
., 1907.
230. Abu Ma'shar. De magnis coinctiombus. Erhard Ratdolt. -
Augsburg, 1489.
231. Aime Puech. St. Jean Chrisostome et les moeurs de son temps. -
Paris, 1891.
232. Albright W.F. From the Stone Age to Christianity. - N.Y.,1957.
233. Almagestu Cl. Ptolemaei Phelusiensis Alexandrini. Anno Virgi-
nei Partus, 1515.
234. Apianus P. Cosmographicus Liber Petri Apiani mathematici
studiose collectus. - Landshutae, impensis P.Apiani, 1524.
235. Arnim H. Sprachliche Forschungen zur Chronologie der
platonischen Dialoge. - Sitzungen Wiener Akademie. - 1912. -
Vol.269. - 3 Abh.
236. Baily F. The Catalogues of Ptolemy, Ulugh Beigh, Tycho Brahe,
Halley and Hevelins, deduced from the best authorities. - Royal
Astr. Soc. Memoirs, XIII, 1843, .1-248.
237. Bloch M. La societe feodale. - Paris, 1968.
238. Bode J.E. Claudius Ptolemaeus, Astronom zu Alexandrien im
zweyten Jahrhundert Beobachtung und Beschreibung der Gestirne
und der Bewegung. - Berlin und Stettin, 1795.
239. . Dissertation sur l`incertitude des cinq premiers
si'eles de l`histoire Romanae. - , 1738; , 1886.
240. Borman Z. Astra. - 1596.
241. Broughton T.R.S. The Magistrates of the Roman Republic. -
Vol.1,2. - London, 1951-1960.
242. Brugsch H. Recueil de Monuments Egyptiens, dessines sur
lieux. - Leipzig, 1862-1865.
243. Cagnat R. Cours d'epigraphie latine. - 4 ed. - Paris, 1914.
244. Chabas F. Melanges egiptologiques. Deuxieme serie. -
Agiptolog. Zeitschrift. - 1868. - S.49.
245. Champfleury. Historie de la Carricature au Moyen Age. -
Paris, 1867-1871.
246. Chronologie egiptienne d'apres les textes demotiques. Par.
P.W.Pestman. - Papyrologia Lugduno - Batava edidit Institutum
Papyrologicum Universitatis Lugduno - Batavae Moderantibus
M.David et B.A. von Groningen. - Vol. 15. - Lugdunum Batavorum,
1967.
247. Cipolla Carlo M. Money, prices and civilization in the
Mediterranean world. 5-17 century. - Princeton, Princeton Univ.
Press, 1956.
248. Claudii Ptolemaei Magnae Constructionis, id est perfectae
coelestium motuum pertractationis. Lib. XIII. Theonis Alexanrini
in eosdem Commentariorum Libri XI; Basileal apud Ioannem
Waledrum. An. 1538. C. priv. Caes. ad Quinquennium.
249. Claudii Ptolemaei Phelusiensis Alexandrini. Anno Salutis,1528.
250. Clinton H.F. Fasti Hellenici, a civil and litterary chronology
from the earlest times to the death of Augustus. - Oxford,
1830-1841.
251. Corbinianus. Firmamentum Firmianum. - 1731.
252. Craig Harmon. The natural distribution of radiocarbon and the
exchange time of carbon dioxides between atmosphere and sea. -
Tellus. - 1957. - Vol.9. - P.1-17.
253. Crowe C. Carbon-14 activity during the past 5000 year. -
Nature. - 1958. - Vol. 182. - P.470.
254. Degrassi A. Fasti Capitolini, 1954; I Fasti consolari
dell'-impero romano, 1952.
255. Dheily J. Dictionaire Biblique. - Ed.Desclec.Tournai,1964. -
P.193.
256. Dialogus Historicus Palladii episcopi Helenopolis cum
Theodoro. Patrologiae Cursus Completus. Patrologiae Graecae. -
T. LVII. - J.-P. Migne, 1858.
257. Dupont-Sommer A. Les ecript essentiens decouverts pies de la
mer morte. - Paris, 1957.
258. Dupuis C. The origin of all religious worship. - New Orleans,
1872.
259. Filarete Antonio Averlino. Tractat uber die Baukunst. - Wien,
1890.
260. Fine Oronce. Orontii Finaei delphinatis,etc. - 1551.
261. Fischer Fr. Thucydidus reliquiae in papyris et membranis
aigiptiacis servatae. - Lipsiae, 1913.
262. Fricke W., Koff A. FK4. - Verof. Astr. Inst. Heidelberg,
1963, No. 10.
263. Gadol J. Leon Battista Alberti. - Chicago; London, 1969.
264. Georgius Phrantzae. De Vita et Acriptus Georgii Phrantzae.
Patrologiae cursus completus. Series graeca posterior. -
T. CLVI. - J.-P. Migne, 1866.
265. Ginzel F.K. Spezieller Kanon der Sonnen- und Mondfinsternisse.
- Berlin, 1899.
266. Ginzel F.K. Handbuch der Mathematischen und Technischen
Chronologie. - Bd. I-III. - Leipzig, 1906,1911,1914.
267. Ginzel F.K., Wilkens A. Theorie der Finsternisse. - Encykl.
der Wissenschaftten. - 1908. - Bd. VI,2. - S.335.
268. Grienberger C. Catalogus Veteres affixarum lougitudiues et
latitudines cum novis conferens. - Rjmae apud B.Zannetum,
1612.
269. Grierson Philip. Coinage and money in Bysantie empaire. -
Spoleto, 1961.
270. Grierson Philip. Monnaies du Moyen Age. - Fribourg, 1976.
271. Grollenberg L.N. Atlas of the Bible. - N.Y., 1956.
272. Hansen P. Ecliptische Tafeln fur die Konjunktionen des Mondes
und der Sonne. - Leipzig, 1857.
273. Hansen P. Theorie der Sonnenfinsternisse und verwandten
Erscheinungen. - Leipzig, 1859.
274. Hauvette A. Herodote historien des querres medicules. - Paris,
1894.
275. Havet'a E. La modernite des prophetes. - Paris, 1891.
276. Heis. Die Finsternisse wahren des pelop. Krieges. Progr. d.
Fried. Wilh: Gimn. - Koln, 1834.
277. Hignett C. Xerxes Invasion of Greece. - Oxford, 1963.
278. Hincks E. The Egyptian Dynasties of Manetho. - The Journal of
Sacred Literature. - London, 1864.
279. Historiae bysantinae scriptores post Theophanem. Patrologiae
cursus completus. Series graeca posterior. - T. CIX. - J.-P.
Migne, 1863.
280. Hochart. De l`authenticite des Annales et des Histoires de
Tacite. - Paris, 1890.
281. Hofflit D. The Bright Star Catalogue. - Yale Univ. Obs. New
Haven Connecticut, USA, 1982.
282. Hoffman. Samtliche bei griechishen und lateinschen
Schriftstellern des Altertums erwahnte Sonnrn- und
Mondfinsternisse - Nummer. - Triest, 1885.
283. Horster M. Brunelleschi und Alberti in ihrer Stellung zur
romischen Antike. - Florenz, 1973.
284. Ideler L. Handbuch der mathematischen und technischen
Chronologie. - Berlin, 1825-1826, Band 1-2.
285. Ioannis Cantacuzeny. Opera Omnia. Patrologiae curcus
completus. Series graeca. - T. CLIII, CLIV. - J.-P. Migne, 1866.
286. Isidori Junioris. Hispalensis episcopi: De responsione
mundi. - 1472.
287. Jurku A. Ausgrabungen in Palestina - Syrien. - Halle, 1956.
288. Keller W. Und die Bibel hat doch Recht. - Dusseldorf, 1958.
289. Kenyon K.M. Digging in Jericho. - London, 1957.
290. Knobel E.B. British Cshool of Archaeology in Egipt and
Egyptian Recearch Account. - London, 1908.
291. Kobold H. Finsternisse. Handworterbuch der Astronomie. -
Herausg. von W.Valentiner. - Bd. I. - Breslau, 1897.
292. Langeteau C. Tables pour le calcul des syzy gies ecliptiques,
Connaissanse des Temps pour 1846. - Paris, 1843, 1850.
293. L`art de verifier les dates faites historiques. - Ed. par des
Benedictines. - 1 ed., Paris, 1750; 2 ed., Paris, 1770; 3 ed.,
Paris, 1783, 1784, 1787.
294. Le Saint voyage de Jnerusalem de seigneur d'Anglure. Pubne par
F.Bonnardot et A.Longnon. - Paris, 1878.
295. Lehmann P. Tafeln zur Berechnung der Mondphasen und
Sonnen- und Mondfinsternisse. - Berlin, 1882.
296. Leupoldus de Austria. Compilatio de Astrorum Scientia, cuts.
1489.
297. Lhotsky A. Auf Satze und Vortrage. - Halle, 1970-1972.
298. Lilly W. An Introduction to Astrology. - London, G.Bell, 1939.
299. Lubienietski S. Theatrum Cometicum, etc. - Amstelodami,
1666-1668.
300. Lubienietski S. Historia universalis omnium Comrtarum. - 1681.
301. ..
. - , 1852.
302. Manuel Chrisoloras. Manuels Chrisolorae Vita et scripta.
Patrologiae cursus completus. Series graeca posterior. - T.
CLVI. - J.-P. Migne, 1866.
303. Manuel II Palaeologus. Laudatio funebris fratris sui Theodori
Palaeologi Despotae. Patrologiae cursus completus. Series
graeca posterior. - T. CLVI. - J.-P. Migne, 1866.
304. Mapy severni a jizni hvezdne oblohy. - Praha, Kartografie
Praha, 1971.
305. Miller W. The Latins in the Levant. A History of frankish
Greece in 1204-1566. - London, 1908.
306. Mommsen T. Die Romische Chronologie bis auf Casar. Berlin,
1859, 2 Aufl.
307. Montucla J.E. Historie des mathematiques. - T.IV. - Paris,
1802.
308. Musee Royal de Naples: Peintures, bronzes et statues erotiques
du cabinet secret, avec les explanations de M.C.F. (Cesar
Famin). - Paris, 1857.
309. Myres J. Herodotus. Father of History. - Oxford, 1953.
310. Neugebauer Dr.P.V. Abgekurzte Tafeln der Sonne und grossen
Planeten. - Berlin, 1904.
311. Neugebauer O. Astronomische Chronologie. - Berlin und Leipzig,
1929.
312. Neugebauer O. Specieller Kanon der Sonnenfinsternisse.
Erganzungsheft, Astron. Nachr. 8, 4. - Kiel, Verlag der
Astronomischen Nachrichten, 1931.
313. Newcomb S. On the reccurence of solar eclipses with tables of
eclipses. - Astronomical Papers (Washington). - 1882. - Vol.1,
N 1.
314. Newton Isaac. The Chronology of Ancient Kingdoms amended. To
which is Prefix'd, A Short Chronicle from the First Memory of
Things in Europe, to the Conquest of Persia by Alexander the
Great. - London, J.Tonson, 1728.
1988 . :
Histories and Mysteries of Man LTD. Lavender Walk, London SW11
1LA, 1988.
315. Newton R.R. Astronomical evidence concerning non-gravitational
forces in the Earth-Moon system. - Astrophys. Space Sci. -
1972. - Vol. 16. - P. 179-200.
316. Newton R. Two uses of ancient astronomy. - Philos. Trans. of
the Royal Soc. of London. Ser. A. - 1974. - Vol. 276. -
P. 99-115.
317. Nicolai Copernici Thorunensis de Revolutionibus Orbium Coelestium
Libri VI. Ex. auctoris autographio recudi curavit Societas
Copernicana Thorunensis. - Berolini, 1873.
318. Noth M. Die Welt der Alten Testament. - Berlin, 1957.
319. Oertel F. Herodots agyptischen Logos und die Glaubwurdigkeit
Herodots. - Berlin, 1970.
320. Oppolzer Th. Kanon der Sonnen und Mondfinsternisse. -
Wien, K.K.Hof- und Staatsdruckerei, 1887.
321. Oppolzer Th. Tafeln zur Berechnung der Mondfinsternisse. -
Wien, 1883.
322. Oppolzer Th. Syzygientafeln fur den Mond. - Leipzig,
Astronomiche Gesselschaft, 1881.
323. Owen G.F. Archaelogy and the Bible. - N.Y., 1961.
324. Paulus Venetus. Philisiphiae naturalis compendium clarissimi
philosophi Pauli Veneti: una libro de compositione mundi,
etc. - Paris, J.Lambert (s.d.).
325. Pearce A. The science of the stars. - London, Glien & C,
1898.
326. Pearce A. The text-book of Astrology. - London, Glen & C,
1911.
327. Petavius D. De doctrina temporum. - Vol. 1. - Paris, 1627.
(Petau D. Opus de doctrina temporum, etc. - V.1. -
Antwerpiae, M. DCCV.)
328. Peters C.H.F., Knobel E.B. Ptolemy's catalogue of stars. -
Washington: The Carnegie Inst. of Washington, 1915.
329. Pingre A. Chronologie des eclipses qui ont ete visibles
depuisle le pole boreal jusque vers l'equateur pendant les dix
siecles qui ont precede l'ere Chretienne. - Paris, 1787.
330. Pogo A. Additions and corrections to Oppolzer's Kanon der
Mondfinsternisse. - Astron. Journal. - 1937. - Vol. 43. -
P. 45-48.
331. Ptolemaei Cl. Phelusiensis Alexandrini philosophi et matematici
excellentissimi Phaenomena stellarum 1022 fixarum ad hanc
aetatem reducta, atque seorsum in studiosorum gratiam. Nunc
primum edita, Interprete Georgio Trapezuntio. Excessum
Coloniai Agrippinae. Anno 1537, octavo Calendas 5 Septembers.
332. Ptolemy's Almagest. Transl. and annot. by G.J.Toomer. - London,
1984.
333. Radini Tedeschi. Sideralis abyssus. - Luteciae, Impressum opa
T.Kees, 1514.
334. Raska. Chronologie der Bibel. - Berlin, 1878.
335. Robert C. Archaologische Hermeneutig. - Berlin, 1919.
336. Robertson J.M. Pagan christs; studies in comparative
hierology. - London, Watts & C, 1911.
337. Ross. Tacitus and Bracciolini. The Annals forged in the XV-th
century. - London, 1878.
338. Rostovzeff M. Social and Economic History of the Roman
Empire. - Paris, 1957.
339. Rowley H.H. The Old Testament and Modern Study. - Oxford,
1961.
340. Sacro Bosco J. de. Opusculum Johannis de Sacro busto spericum,
cu figuris optimus ei novis textu in se, sive ambiguitate
declarantibus. - Leipzig, 1494.
341. Sacro Bosco J. de. Sphera materialis. - Nurnberg. Gedruckt
durch J.Getkneckt, 1516.
342. Sacro Bosco J. de. Opusculu de Sphaera... clarissimi
philosophi Ioannis de Sacro busto. - Viennae Pannoniae, 1518.
343. Sayce. Herodotus I-III. The ancient empire of the East. -
London, 1883.
344. Scaliger I. Opus novum de emendatione temporum. - Lutetiac.
Paris, 1583. (Thesaurum temporum, 1606.)
345. Schaarschmidt K. Die Sammlung der Platos Schriften zur
Schreidung der achten von den unechten untersucht. - Bonn, 1866.
346. Schram R. Tafeln zur Berechning der naheren Umstande der
Sonnenfinsternisse. - Wien, 1886.
347. Schram R. Reductionstafeln fur den Oppolzerischen Finsternis
Kanon zum Ubergang auf die Ginzelschen Correctionen. - Wien,
1889.
348. Schram R. Kalendariographische und chronologische Tafeln. -
Leipzig, 1908.
349. Schroter J. Specieller Kanon der zentralen Sonnen- und
Mond-finsternisse. - Kristiania, 1923.
350. Schwahn P. Mathematische Theorie der astronomischen
Finsternisse. - Leipzig, 1910.
351. Schwegler T. Die Biblische Urgeschichte. - Munchen, 1960.
352. Siebeck H. Zur Chronologie der platonischen Dialoge. - Halle,
1873.
353. Spielberg W. Die Glaubwurdigkeit von Herodots Bericht uber
Agypten. - Berlin, 1926.
354. Steeb J. Coelum sephiroticum Hebraeorum, etc. - Mainz, publ.
1679.
355. Struve O. Libroram in biblioteca Speculae Pulcovensis
catalogus systematicus. - Petropoli, 1860.
356. Sueton. Die zwolf Casaren, nach der Ubersetzung v. A.Stahr neu
hdsg. - Munshen, Leipzig, 1912.
357. Suhle A. Mittelalterische Brakteaten. - Leipzig, 1965.
358. Tesnierio Ioanne. Opus Matematicum octolibrum. - Coloniae
Agrippinae, apud J.Birckmannum & W.Richwinum, 1562.
359. Teutsch Astronomei. Astronomia. - Woodcuts, 1545.
360. The Cambridge medieval history. IV. The Bysantie Empire. -
Cambridge, Cambridge Univ. Press, 1966-1967.
361. The history of Herodotus. - London, 1858.
362. The place of astronomy in the ancient world. - A discussion
organized jointly for the Rojal Society and the British Academy.
Philos. Trans. of the Rojal. Soc. of London. Ser. A. - 1974. -
Vol. 276. - P. 1-276.
363. Thierry Amedee. St. Jean Chrysostome et l'imperatrice
Eudoxie. - Paris, 1872.
364. Thorndike Linn. A History of Magic and Experimental Science. -
Vol. 2. - N.-Y., 1923.
365. Wissowa Pauly. Real-Encyclopadie der Klassischen
Altertumwissenschaft. hrsg. von Kroll.
366. Wittkower R. Architectural Principles in the Age of
Humanizm. - Paris, 1960.
367. Wolf R. Handbuch der Astronomie, ihrer Geschichte und
Literatur. - Bd. II. - Zurich, 1892.
368. Wooley L. Exavation at Ur. - N.Y., 1955.
369. Wright G.E. Biblical Archeology. - Philadelphia; London, 1957.
370. Zadkiel. The Grammar of Astrology. - London, J.Cornish, 1849.
371. Zech J. Astronomische Untersushungen uber die wichtigeren
Finsternisse, welche von den Schriftstellern des klassischen
Altertums erwahnt werden. - Leipzig, 1853.
372. Zevi B., Battisti E., Garin E., Malle L. Alberti. -
Enciclopedia universale dell'arte. - Vol. I. - Venecia; Poma,
1958.
373. .., ..
- . - .,
"", ,
1980.
374. .. . -
. .
. - ,1980. - .161-166.
375. ..
. -
. - ., . , . 15, 1980,
. 99-124.
376. ..
. - 3-
. - ,
, 1981. - .2. - .211-212.
377. ..
. - . - 1981. - .258, N 6. - .1326-1330.
378. ..
. -
. .
- . - ,1981.-
.63. - .136-150.
379. .. -
. - .,1981, , . ,
. 3672. . 9.11.81 ., N 072017. - C.1-100.
380. Fomenko .. The jump of the second derivative of the Moon's
elongation. - Celestial Mechanics. - 1981. - V.29. - P.33-40.
381. Fomenko A.T. Some new empirico-statictical methods of datihg
and the analysis of present global chronology. 1981. The
British Library. Department of printed books. Cup. 918/87.
382. ..
. - . - ,
- -, 1982. - .20. - .98-113.
383. .. . - " ",
1982, N 11, . 26-29.
384. .., ..
- . -
-. . XY,
, . - ,
- -, 1982, . 576, . 24-43.
385. .. -
. -
, 1983, . 268, N 6, . 1322-1327, 0,5 ..
386. ..
. -
. - .: - , 1983. - .21. - .106-152.
387. A.T.
. -
. - .: - ( ), 1983. - .86-109.
388. B.B., A.T.
. -
. . - .:
, 1983. - .101-107.
English translation: Fedorov V.V., Fomenko A.T. Statistical
Estimation of Chronological Nearness of Historical Texts. -
Journal of Soviet Math., 1986, v. 32, No. 6. - .668-675.
389. A.T. . - "
", 1983, N 11, . 85-92.
390. A.T.
. - . - : -
-, 1983, . 21, . 40-59.
391. A.T.
. -
. - : - -,
1983, . 22, . 40.
392. A.T.
.
- . - , -
-, 1984, . 24, . 49-66.
393. A.T. -
. -
. . - .: ,
1984, .154-177.
394. A.T.
. -
"
". - .: - (
), 1984, .135-136.
395. A.T.
. - . .
. - ., , 1985, .49, .335-342. - (
.)
396. A.T.
. - 4-
.
- ,
, 1985, . 3, . 246-248.
397. .., ..
. -
. - .: - , 1985, . 22,
. 119-131.
398. Fomenko .. New empirico-statistical dating methods and
statistics of certain astronomical data. -
. . - ., , 1986, . 2, . 892.
399. .., ..
. -
. -
., , 1986, . 107-129.
400. .., .., ..
. -
. . - .:
, 1986, . 33-45.
401. ..
. -
. . - .: , 1987, . 33-45.
402. .., ..
"-" ( "" XYI -
XYII .). -
. - .: - , , 1987, . 163-181.
403. Fomenko .. Duplicates in mixed sequences and a frequency
duplication principle. Methods and applications. - Probability
theory and athematical statistics. Proceeding of the Fourth
Vilnius Conference (24-29 June 1985) - VNU Science Press,
Utrecht, Netherlands, 1987, v.16, p.439-465.
404. .., ..
. -
. - ., - , 1988,
. 23, . 104-121.
405. .., .., ..
. -
. . - .,
, 1988, . 59-78.
406. Fomenko .. Empirico-Statistical Methods in Ordering Narrative
Texts. - International Statistical Review. - 1988. - V. 566,
No. 3. - P. 279-301.
407. Fomenko A.T., Kalashnikov V.V., Nosovsky G.V. When was
Ptolemy's star catalogue in "Almagest"compiled in reality?.
Preprint, No. 1989-04, ISSN 0347-2809. Dept. of Math. Chalmers
Univ. of Technology, The University of Goteborg. Sweden.
408. .., .., ..
,
"". - 5-
. -
, ,
1989, . 3, . 271-272.
409. .., ..
.-
5-
. - , -
. 1989, . 4, . 111-112.
410. .., ..
. -
.
. - ., - ( ), 1989. -
. 161-180.
411. .., .., ..
. -
, 1989, . 307, N 4, . 829-832.
412. Fomenko A.T., Kalashnikov V.V., Nosovsky G.V. When was
Ptolemy's star catalogue in "Almagest" compiled in reality?
Statistical Analysis. - Acta Applicandae Mathematical. - 1989. -
V.17. - P.203-229.
413. .., ..
. - .
. - ., 1989. -
"". . - .138-148.
414. Fomenko A.T. Mathematical Statistics and Problems of Ancient
Chronology. A New Approach. - Acta Applicandae Mathematical. -
1989. Vol.17. P.231-256.
415. .., ..
(
). - .
. - ., , 1989. - .112-125.
416. ...
. (
, ,
.) - ., - . -,
1990.
417. .. . - ., , 1990. -
, , . : ,
. - N 7.
418. Fomenko A.T., Kalashnikov V.V., Nosovsky G.V. Geometrical and
Statistical Methods of Analysis of Star Configurations. Dating
Ptolemy's Almagest. - CRC-Press. 1993. USA.
419. Fomenko A.T. Empirico-Statistical Analysis of Narrative Material
and its Applications to Historical Dating.
Volume 1: The Development of the Statistical Tools.
Volume 2: The Analysis of Ancient and Medieval Records.
Kluwer Academic Publishers. 1994. The Netherlands.
420. Fomenko A.T., Kalashnikov V.V., Nosovsky G.V. The dating of
Ptolemy's Almagest based on the coverings of the stars and on
lunar eclipses. - Acta Applicandae Mathematicae. 1992. vol.29,
pp.281-298.
421. Fomenko A.T., Kalashnikov V.V., Nosovsly G.V. Statistical analysis
and dating of the observations on which Ptolemy's "Almagest" star
catalogue is based. - In: Probability theory and mathematical
statistics. Proc.of the Fifth Vilnius Conference. 1990, Moklas,
Vilnius, Lithuania; VSP, Utrecht, The Netherlands, vol.1,
pp.360-374.
422. .., .., ..
. - ", .
". . 1990. .23. , -
"". .78-92.
423. .., .., ..
"". - . 1990.
.313, N 6, .1315-1320.
424. Fomenko A.T., Rachev S.T. Volume Functions of Historical Texts
and the Amplitude Correlation Principle. - Computers and the
Humanities. 1990. vol.24, pp.187-206.
425. Frank E.Manuel. Isaac Newton Historian. - The Belknap Press of
Harvard University Press. Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1963.
426. Edwin Johnson, M.A. The Rise of English Culture. - Williams
and Norgate. London, New York, G.P.Putnam's Sons, 1904.
427. Edwin Johnson, M.A. The Rise of Christendom. - London, Kegan
Paul, Trench, Trubner, & Co. Ltd. 1890.
428. . .
( XXIII). - , , 1980.
429. ... . (
.
. ).
, - - - , 1993 .
430. .., .., ...
. ( ) -
, - "", 1995.
431. ...
( ?). . - , -
- . 1993.
432. .., ...
, . (. .
). 1. . 2. , .
, 1995, - -
.
433. ... . .
- , 1996, - -
.
434. .., ... . , , ,
, . . -
, 1996, - "".
Last-modified: Wed, 11 Mar 1998 14:32:32 GMT