-------------------------
"", 2, 1999 , "
".
---------------------------------------------------------------
"":
""
..
!
( " ",
"", "")
,
.
,
.
"" -. ,
,
.
..
.-. . ..
------------------------------
, - .
1) XV-XVI ,
.
2)
XVI-XVII .
(1540-1609) (1583-1652).
,
, -, .
XVII-XX .
, .
(
).
, ,
.
-
1979 .
,
. ,
,
.
3)
.
- XVI-XVII .
, .
, , ,
. , ,
, .
.
, .
4) , "
",
. - ,
.
(
),
. 1970- .
1990 .
- . ,
20 , , ,
.
5) " " .
,
. , -
.
.
., .
XVI-XVII ,
, .
. , .., ., . .
, ,
.
, ,
,
.
6) , ,
, .
. ,
( ) ,
.
. ( )
,
.
. " "
"". .
7) , " "
( ,
..). , -, . ,
. -
. ,
. , - ,
.
. , ,
,
. - ,
( )
, , ,
.
8) ,
"",
. ,
,
. ,
. , ,
- .
30 -,
( ).
,
, , , " ", " ",
"", "", " ", "", " ",
"", " ", " ", " ",
" ", "", " ",
"", " ", "" .
(
) " ".
22 1998
,
.., .
. , ..,
(29 1981 ),
. 1981
-. ..
... ..
, .
. "" ,
( ?)
.
. ,
" ".
" ".
. ,
: << ...
.
, .
>>.
. .
( ) 9 1984
(. 18).
" "
.
. , ..,
... ..
.. : <<
,
..,
, ,
. ,
" "
, ,
- - >> (8
1984 ).
" ", 1984 , No.1,
, , , .
" .....
. , , ,
,
- " (.115).
"..
, .
, ,
- " (.116).
".. ,
,
,
, , ,
, " (.119).
,
(22 1998 ) .
.
, , ..,
- .., ..,
.. ().
.. 1998
. ..,
.
,
.
,
. "", ,
, . [9], .165.
,
. ,
,
. , . "" 29
1997 ., .. "", No.2, 1997 .
, , .
.
. ""
.
, ,
(
..),
. , ,
,
.
.
.
1) ,
, .
. , ,
.
, ,
. , "",
.
2) , -
.
,
. ,
,
. (
) : ,
, . . ,
. :
?
3) (. . , .
, . .) , .
? , << , >>.
.
- , . . :
- ?
, , -,
. , .
, ,
.
: .
:
.
, ,
, ""
.
. ,
. . ,
, , ,
.
4) , ,
, . , ,
, , "
". :
? ,
, ( ) .
5) . ,
" " (,
, . .), -
. . ,
. ,
- ,
. . ,
,
, .
"": , ( )
, , ,
.
6) ,
, .
.
7) -
.
, - , - ""
" " (
, , . [9] .. [11]).
,
"" .
, ,
.
2 "" 1997 ,
.
.
.
,
: "
" (.76).
" "
(.76), ""
,
. - .... .. ....
... .... ...
, .. 1983
" " (1983, No.12) ( ..),
.
, .. .
( ).
.
... .
.. [7].
"" ..,
"".
, .
, , ,
, ,
[4]. ,
600 1300 .
. ,
.
, .
.... . ..
" .
" [4], , (
).
, ""
"".
" " (.75)
.. ,
1987 [1]. .
, .
. - 150 , ,
- 1000-1500 .
... (. ),
"" ,
.. XVII .
.
, .. ""
( ""
- 150 ) ""
"" !
, ..
"", , , 1 , 1 .. "", -
- ,
.
, .. .
.., .. .. [8].
.., .. .. "
" [4]. 1995 ,
( ) - 1993. ,
, . ,
, ,
, .. -
"".
"". ..
. , ..
"". ..
.
..
. -,
. -,
, .
, ...
,
,
. ,
, .. .
"" .
.. ,
,
(
), - . "
- .....
8 ( ), 504 "
(.75). ,
" ",
. (
"" ..), ,
( ),
8- ,
.
, .75 , ""
" " ,
.. " " (1991, No.7).
.. ,
, . 1991
""
. .
..,
"",
. ..
, ,
. , , .
.. ,
.
, "
". . , ,
,
.
.. ""
.. ... ,
.. ..
. " 1977
, .. ... ,
. ,
".
.. : << 1992 . ...
, ... 1992 ,
"
",
>>.
.. 1990 .
1991 .. : "
,
... (),
,
( ), .
".
.. : " .
1992 . ... , ,
.
".
<< ,
.. (
),
.., , (
..). .. ,
. , .. , "
80- - 90- ,
".
( ..).
..
, "" ,
; ..
. ,
,
.
. .. " "
. , -
, - .. " "
.
,
"" .., . ,
, >>. (
..).
"". .75-76
.. ( ).
.. ,
,
. , .
, ,
. - .
,
" ".
, ,
. .
"" ,
, . ,
, ..
, .
"",
" " .. ..
.
.75 "" , ..
, << ""
>>. , ..
[4].
[4], .176-178. ,
,
, ,
.
,
. ,
. ""
.
,
. , .
,
. ., , [3],[5].
..,
. ..
.. [1].
"- " [2].
, .
: 13- ..
- 100 . ..
.. . .
..
,
.
' .
. ,
.., "" .
"" ..
,
, .
- .
, . ,
? ..
. [1]
" " , [2]
- .
: "... , ...
" [2], .183. ,
-
13
- ^2 . .
10 .
30 . ,
, ..
-
- 20-30 .
2-3 . , ,
.., - 1000-1500 .
.
.., ^2 . , ,
- .
, ^2
, ,
. ,
^2 .. (
^2 ), ,
.
.
. ^2 -
. ,
.
, , 778, 779, 780.
779 ^2
, .. ^2 ,
779, . '
,
..
, , , 900 1900 ..
^2
780. 779
. 98 Heis.
779 . . [3]. , ^2
.
, ..
, ..,
"", 13- ..
- 100 .
, "".
..
. , "" ..
, .. .
, , "",
. .. . ,
.
"" .. ..
310 ... - 360 .
. .. ""
, .
:
"" 30-40 .
( ) - 3 .
,
. ,
"" ..
. , " ".
.. << "
">>, 1998 .
... , , 1997, .296-303.
, ..
.
, . "",
(. ).
. , ,
. ,
, . "
" , , .
...
. . "" -
: "
X
?!" (.297). : " "
(.301). ..
,
, , : " - ,
, " (.303). : "...
... , ,
, "
(.303). , ""
" ". - , -
"
",
... , ..
(1987 ., 294, No.2, .310-313),
"", ,
.
" ".
, .. .
,
.. ( )
.
[6]. , ..
..
,
.
. , , ,
, 1,1 .
2,285 , 1,1
2,285 , ' 1733 .
1733 1690 ( ,
),
43 .. : "
, ,
.
0,1
. , 150 "
[6], .75. . -,
0,1 ? -,
"" ,
,
, .
.
. 2,285
1,1 , . 900
.. (,
). , "" ..
..
, .
, .
(
) ,
" ".
.. .. .
- . , .
. : <<
""
, - "" 330 ..
300 ...
,
..>> [6], .75-76.
,
. ,
,
, . ,
X ..
, [6] .
, "",
[4], 1995 .
.. .. . ,
, .
" ",
" ", 1998, No.3, .165-188.
, -
, - ,
. , " "
. , 1925
.. " "
( , 1925, No.1, .157-175),
... .. -
" " " "
1925 (No.4, .133-143).
...
, 1975 " "
, . "
" (1975, No.1., .203-210), .
.. . ,
. ,
" ".
, 1998
. ,
.
.. : " ,
.." (.165).
, .. ,
" ", .
, .. - -,
, , ,
(. [12]), . - .
, " "?
..
: ": ... -
, ,
- " (.188).
, , , , ,
, . ,
, , - ,
. , , -
., - .
,
. , - ,
" ". ,
, , " "
XVII ( -
),
, - ,
. .
, , . ,
. .
- ,
. .
, .
, . , -
, - ,
. , .
- ,
, .
, .
( , , )
. -
?
. (.165-167)
. , .
, .
. , .
.
.168 .
- , ., ,
.
. .
, ..,
, ,
. . ,
,
: , ,
.. ,
. ,
, .
,
, "" .
.
,
. ,
, , ""
,
. "" .
"" ,
1-2 ,
. ,
- ,
.-. (. 169).
.
, ,
.
,
. ,
.. ..
. -
. .
.. " "
" ", 1997, No.11, .30-37 ( ); 1997, No.12,
.10-17 ( ). , ..
.
.
. ,
"
". . , " (..
- .) ,
,
, - " (.169).
.
- ,
. ,
. .
. .
.
.
.171 . , "
,
( - .) ".
. "",
.
.
, .
,
: " ,
. , ,
,
- .. ?" -
.. , "
". , ., "
" (.171).
.
., - .
, . ""
.
" ", .
, ,
330 , 1050 1800 .
,
. ,
.
, , ,
.
. . : "
... ... -"
(.172). , , ,
,
,
.
, .
: " ,
, ,
" (.172).
? , . , ""
?
.
, () .
,
, . ,
" " XIII-XIV ..
, , " "
XIV-XVII .. XV-XX
.
, XV-XX
,
. . ""
. ", , ...
, 600, 200 "
(.172). " "
. ,
, , .
. " " "
", .,
"" , .
,
" " XX , , XIX . .
,
(,
" "), , ,
, ,
(""),
.
,
( )
(
). ,
" ",
,
. .
, .
(, ) ,
,
- ( ),
,
( ). -
. .
" ".
, ., -
"", - .
. .
-.
.
, ?
, , (
) , ,
, - ,
.
,
. , ,
XVI ,
. , , .
, . ,
, ,
XVII-XVIII . , - .
, . ,
, ..
. , ,
. , ,
. ,
,
. ,
. ,
. , ,
.
. ,
,
( ) ,
.
. ,
. , , .
182 , "
",
. . 606 ""
: " (. ARMENIA) = . . 6".
. : <<. " ,
"" (.
4)... . >> - ..
, ,
""
. ,
, ,
. , , . "",
" ", .
, ""
- .
"" .
606. " (. ARMENIA) = "
,
,
. 6, 609
. , 609
.
. ,
.
.
, " "
6,
4, 606, ,
.. 6
.
, .
606. ,
" ", ,
"", ,
606 609 .
"" .
. ,
. .
.
.
... .. " " "
", No.14(244), 9-15 1998 , "
, - ?" "" 11
1998 .
, " ",
. , .. ,
. , ,
.., ,
( ..).
,
- - ,
- .
,
, , ,
. ,
, ..
..?
, "" ,
: " , , ,
, .
". "" : ",
, .
". , ..
,
.
.
, . .. , .
, .., , .
.. : " - , ,
, , " ( ).
.. :
?
:
, . ,
. .. ,
, , ,
, . ?
, .., " ".
"" ..
" " - " "
. ,
. . "
" .
""? , -
. ,
" " - .
, "" . ,
? , .. " ",
,
. ..
,
.
..
"" ... .. ,
-
. : <<
. -
" ">>.
.. ..
.
- . .. ( )
: " , ,
". .. . ,
, .., ..,
.., .., ..,
.
. , "" -
.
.
, .
,
, " ", -
. ,
"" (
),
- "" . .
( )
, ,
-.
, . ,
- ,
- .
, -,
.
, ,
,
.
, . ,
, .
.
, ,
. .
- . ,
, .
1) . . .
. ( ,
,
).
, - , 1990 , 440 .
1996
, - :
... .
. - , - , 1996.
,
- .
. ,
.
. .,
. -------------------------------
2) . . . . (
. .
).
, , - - - , 1993 . 408 .
,
X-XVI . .
,
. , . . , -
. .
--------------------------------
3) A. T. Fomenko, V. V. Kalashnikov, G. V. Nosovskij. Geometrical and
statistical methods of analysis of star configurations. Dating of Ptolemy's
Almagest.
CRC-Press, USA, 1993, 300 p.
1995 :
. . , . . , . . .
<<>>. . - ,
- "", 1995.
-
.
<<>>. , <<>>
600-1300 . ., . .,
. ---------------------------------
4) A. T. Fomenko. Empirico-statistical analysis of narrative material
and its applications to historical dating.
Volume 1. The Development of the Statistical Tools.
Volume 2. The Analysis of Ancient and Medieval Records.
Kluwer Academic Publishers. The Netherlands. 1994.
- .
,
. --------------------------------
5) .. .
( ? ). .
, , - - . 1993, 204
.
, << >>.
---------------------------------
6) . . , .. .
, . (. . ).
1. . 382 .
2. , . 290 .
, 1995, - -
.
,
1996 .
.
,
<<- >>, , <<
>>, .
, -
. ,
. ----------------------------------
7) . . . . .
1,2.
, , - -
, 1996.
.
, -. , ""
, , -
XI-XVI .
, , , .
---------------------------------
8) .., ... . , , , ,
. .
, - "", 1996.
.
""
"" = . "
, ",
, "" -.
. ,
,
, - "" XVII-XIX .
.
, ""
- XIV-XV .
,
.
.
----------------------------------------------------------------
9) .., ... . 1,2. , -
"", 1996.
,
.
------------------------------------------------------------------
10) .., ... . - , 1997,
- .
------------------------------------------------------------------
11) .., ...
. - , , 1997.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
12) .., ... . (-
. ). 1,2. -
. - "", 1998.
1. .., ... << ""
>>. , 1987,
.294, No.2, .310-313. 2. .., ... <<
""
>>. - . ,
, 1989, .18. 3. Peters C.H.F., Knobel E.B. Ptolemy's Cataloge
of Stars. A
revision of Almagest. - Washington: The Carnegie Inst. of
Washington, 1915. 4. .., .., ...
"".
. - , , 1995.
CRC-Press 1993 :
A. T. Fomenko, V. V. Kalashnikov, G. V. Nosovski. Geometrical
and Statistical Methods of Analysis of Star
Configurations. Dating of Ptolemy's Almagest. - CRC-Press, USA, 1993.
5. .. . - , ,
1985. 6. .., .. " "
. - , 1983, No.12,
.68-83. 7. ...
. - ., , 1990; ,
1996). 8. .., .., ...
. -
, 307, No.4, 1989. 9. .. . -
" ", 1998, No.3,
.165-188. 10. ... " , -
?"
- "", 11 1998 . 11. ... "
". "",
1997, No.2, .70-74. 12. -
-;
. - , - , 1982.
-----------------------------------
1945 , (),
( ),
( ),
- , ,
-
.
,
.
1996 ( )
. 180 , 24 ,
, ,
, ,
, .
- ,
.
1958 , - (, 1988),
, ,
, ,
, .
(),
- , ,
.
-
, .
-------------------------------------------------
.. 1999 .
1991
.. : "
, ...
(), ,
( ),
. ".
.. ,
, .
.. "",
.
..,
. . novpismo.tif,
.
Last-modified: Thu, 18 Nov 1999 19:01:58 GMT